The Big Bang Theory and Karl Popper’s Theory of Falsifiability: Where Did We Come From, Who Are We, and Where Are We Going?

In this blog post, we examine the fundamental questions posed by Paul Gauguin’s painting ‘Where Do We Come From? What Are We? Where Are We Going?’ from the perspectives of the Big Bang theory, the cosmic microwave background, the theory of inflation, and Karl Popper’s concept of falsifiability.

 

Where Did We Come From?

The painting ‘Where Do We Come From? Who Are We? Where Are We Going?’ by the Post-Impressionist artist Paul Gauguin captures the fundamental questions of human existence within a single canvas. On the right side of the painting, a young child is depicted alongside three women. This can be interpreted as symbolizing the question, “Where did we come from?” In the center of the painting is a figure picking fruit, which can be interpreted as representing the question “Who are we?” At the far left is an elderly woman facing death, which connects to the question “Where Do We Go?” This masterpiece, measuring approximately 139.1 × 374.6 cm, was created during a psychologically difficult period in Gauguin’s life marked by financial hardship and family problems. In this work, Gauguin addressed fundamental questions regarding human origins, identity, the purpose of life, and destiny. In fact, the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, which houses the painting, describes it as a work that poses enduring questions about human origins, identity, purpose, and destiny.
“Where do we come from? Who are we? Where are we going?” Religion and philosophy have each offered their own answers to these three questions. In Christianity, it is believed that in the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth—that is, the universe—and that humans were created in the image of God, the Creator. In Eastern philosophy, one can find reflections on the origins of humans and all things, most notably in Laozi’s concept of “Taiyi Shengshui” (太一生水). Laozi mentioned “Tai Yi Sheng Shui (太一生水)” in the ‘Daodejing’; here, “Tai Yi” can be understood as a concept referring to the ultimate being that serves as the source of all things. However, it is important to distinguish that the explanations of the origin of the universe in ancient thought differ in nature and verification methods from the cosmology of modern science.
In addition, religion and philosophy offer various answers regarding human identity and the meaning of existence. However, some of these answers are difficult to address through verification or falsification via natural scientific observation or experimentation. Therefore, if we apply Karl Popper’s falsificationism—a standard in the philosophy of science—it is appropriate to classify such claims as religious or philosophical assertions rather than scientific theories. In this article, I intend to examine the answers modern science offers to the three philosophical questions mentioned earlier: “Where did we come from? Who are we? Where are we going?” I will explore, from the perspectives of basic physics, chemistry, and cosmology, the processes through which we have arrived at our present existence; in doing so, I will consider the criterion of “scientific” primarily from the perspective of Karl Popper’s concept of falsifiability.
Our bodies are composed of various compounds. A significant portion of our bodies consists of water, and various organic compounds—including proteins and fats—are intricately bound together. These compounds, in turn, are composed of elements such as hydrogen, carbon, oxygen, and nitrogen. Therefore, the question “Where did we come from?” can, in a sense, be considered in the same context as the question of where the elements that make up our bodies came from. Modern science does not explain that all elements were created at once during the Big Bang. Immediately after the Big Bang, atomic nuclei of light elements—primarily hydrogen and helium, along with trace amounts of lithium—were formed, while most of the heavier elements, including carbon, oxygen, and iron, were created later through various astrophysical processes such as nuclear fusion inside stars and supernova explosions. Therefore, the matter that makes up our bodies can be said to be the result of the early history of the universe, the history of stars, and the process of planetary formation, all of which unfolded over a long period of time.
Although the Big Bang theory is often described using the term “big bang,” it does not simply refer to an event in which some matter exploded in empty space and spread out in all directions. In modern cosmology, the Big Bang refers to the process by which the extremely hot and dense early universe expanded and cooled to evolve into the universe we see today. Therefore, it is more appropriate to understand the Big Bang not as an explosion that occurred at a specific point in space, but as a cosmological process in which space itself has been expanding.
There is a great deal of observational evidence supporting the Big Bang theory as a robust scientific theory. One such piece of evidence is the abundance of light elements formed in the early universe. For a few seconds to a few minutes after the Big Bang, the universe was in a state of extreme heat and high density; during this time, protons and neutrons combined to form the atomic nuclei of light elements, including hydrogen and helium. Since the conditions necessary for the formation of heavy elements did not persist long enough in the early universe, hydrogen and helium also account for the overwhelming majority of ordinary matter in the universe today. In particular, it is predicted that hydrogen and helium in the primordial universe have a mass ratio of approximately 3 to 1—that is, about 75% hydrogen and 25% helium—and this prediction generally agrees well with observations. Therefore, it is more accurate to say “the mass ratio of hydrogen to helium is approximately 3:1” rather than using the expression “the ratio of hydrogen to helium atoms is 3:1” as in the original text.
Another important piece of evidence for the Big Bang theory is the cosmic microwave background radiation. Since the early universe was in a very hot and opaque plasma state, light could not travel freely. As the universe expanded and its temperature dropped, after about 380,000 years, electrons and atomic nuclei combined to form neutral atoms, allowing light to travel freely with almost no interaction with matter. The cosmic microwave background (CMB) that we observe today is light from this very period, whose wavelength has been stretched by the expansion of the universe and is now observed as microwave radiation at a temperature of approximately 2.725 K. Therefore, the statement in the original text that the cosmic microwave background arose 3 minutes after the Big Bang should be corrected to “approximately 380,000 years later.”
The discovery of the cosmic microwave background provided crucial observational evidence for the Big Bang theory. In particular, NASA’s COBE satellite precisely measured that the cosmic microwave background has a nearly perfect blackbody spectrum and an average temperature of approximately 2.725 K. It also detected minute temperature variations—known as anisotropy—across the entire sky, with fluctuations of about one ten-thousandth. Subsequently, the WMAP and Planck satellites measured these variations with even greater precision. These minute variations reflect density fluctuations in the early universe and served as the seeds for the formation of massive cosmic structures, including stars and galaxies, through gravitational processes.
For a long time, various scientists proposed alternative explanations for the Big Bang theory and attempted to verify or refute it. A prime example is the steady-state theory proposed by Fred Hoyle and others. The steady-state theory posited that even as the universe expands, new matter is continuously created, thereby maintaining a constant average density. However, the discovery of the cosmic microwave background and precise observations provided strong evidence for the explanation that the present universe evolved from a hot, high-density early universe, and the Steady-State Theory lost its status as the mainstream cosmological theory. Thus, scientific theories gain acceptance not simply because many people believe in them, but through the process of explaining new observational results and being compared with competing hypotheses.

 

Who Are We?

We have seen that while the cosmic microwave background appears nearly uniform throughout the universe, precise observations reveal subtle variations. These variations are deeply connected to the structure of the universe that allowed us to exist. If the early universe had been completely uniform, it would have been difficult for matter to clump together under the force of gravity to form stars and galaxies in the way we see today. As very small density differences in the early universe were gradually amplified by gravity, the stars, galaxies, galaxy clusters, and massive cosmic structures we see today were formed. NASA also explains that these minute density differences observed in the CMB served as the seeds that later gave rise to the first stars and galaxies.
Therefore, we can also consider the reason we have become distinct beings in connection with this history of the universe. We all live in a universe where stars like the Sun could exist; as the Solar System and Earth formed and life evolved, we arrived at our current state as human beings. Gravity plays a decisive role in the formation of stars and planets. Matter originating from small density fluctuations in the early universe gradually clumped together under the influence of gravity, resulting in the formation of stars and galaxies. Inside stars, elements heavier than hydrogen and helium were created, and these elements were later dispersed into space through the death of stars and various celestial phenomena. Ultimately, the elements that make up our bodies—such as carbon, oxygen, and iron—are also connected to the history of stars from long ago.
Among them, the Sun is a special star to us. Planets formed around the Sun, and among them, Earth developed the conditions necessary for life to thrive, marking the beginning of human history. Of course, the emergence of humanity cannot be explained solely by the existence of the Sun. Numerous conditions—including planetary formation, the presence of water and an atmosphere, the origin of life, and biological evolution—interacted in a complex manner. However, it can be argued that one of the starting points for all these processes was the minute inhomogeneities in the early universe and the gravity that amplified them.
If the early universe had been completely uniform, there would have been virtually no differences in the density of matter even as the universe expanded and cooled, and it would have been difficult for the structures of stars and galaxies, as we see them today, to form. In other words, the reason we are able to exist is that the early universe was not perfectly uniform. The minute anisotropies observed in the cosmic microwave background radiation are important clues revealing these small initial differences. Even in COBE’s observations, these temperature differences were minuscule—amounting to only about one-hundred-thousandth of the average value—but they reflected early density fluctuations capable of growing into the universe’s large-scale structures later on.
So how did these minute differences arise? The original text links this to Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. In fact, modern cosmology widely accepts the explanation that quantum fluctuations in the early universe were amplified to very large scales during the process of inflation, becoming the seeds of density fluctuations. In other words, rather than explaining the anisotropy of the CMB solely through the uncertainty principle—which states that “energy and time cannot be known precisely at the same time”—it is more accurate to explain it by positing that quantum fluctuations were amplified to cosmic scales by inflation.
This is where the theory of inflation, developed by Alan Guth and others, comes into play. The theory of inflation explains that the universe expanded very rapidly during an extremely brief period in its very early history. Although the exact starting time or expansion factor has not been pinpointed to a single specific value, according to this theory, very small fluctuations that existed at the quantum level could be amplified to cosmic scales during the inflationary process. Subsequently, these density fluctuations grew under the influence of gravity, becoming the seeds that formed today’s large-scale structures, such as stars, galaxies, and galaxy clusters. ESA also explains the possibility that the minute temperature variations in the CMB are the result of amplified quantum fluctuations from the inflationary era.
However, one must be cautious about presenting the theory of inflation as if it were a fully proven fact. While inflation is a crucial theoretical framework for explaining the current structure of the universe and various features of the CMB, the direct detection of primordial gravitational waves—which are expected to have been generated during this process—has not yet been confirmed. Although there was an announcement in the past that the BICEP2 experiment had detected traces of primordial gravitational waves, a subsequent analysis combining data from the Planck satellite with BICEP2 and Keck data revealed that a significant portion of the signal at that time originated from dust within the Milky Way. Therefore, the statement in the original text that “the theory of inflation was proven true by gravitational wave research in 2012” does not align with current scientific facts; it is more appropriate to describe the theory of inflation as one that is still undergoing observational verification.

 

Where are we headed?

Since the Big Bang, the universe has been expanding for approximately 13.8 billion years. So, will the universe continue to expand indefinitely? In the past, it was theorized that if the total mass of the universe were sufficiently large, gravity would slow down the expansion and eventually cause the universe to contract again, leading to a “Big Crunch.” Indeed, it remains true that one of the key factors determining the fate of the universe is the relationship between gravity and cosmic expansion. However, current observations have established that the universe is undergoing accelerated expansion, and the term “dark energy” is used to explain the cause of this phenomenon.
Dark energy is not a substance that can be directly observed like visible matter; rather, it is a concept used to explain the universe’s accelerated expansion. The true nature of dark energy remains unknown. The simplest explanation links it to the cosmological constant that appears in Einstein’s general theory of relativity; however, research continues regarding whether dark energy is a new physical entity that changes over time or whether gravitational theory needs to be modified. In particular, recent observations from DESI have yielded results suggesting the possibility that dark energy may vary over time, but it is not yet time to establish this as a new standard theory. Therefore, exactly what dark energy is and what the ultimate fate of the universe will be remain open questions.
The original text explains that, according to the mass-energy equivalence equation E=mc², dark energy will eventually transform into dark matter—that is, mass—causing the universe to contract again; however, this is not a scientifically established fact at present. This is because no general physical law confirming that dark energy transforms into dark matter has been verified, and the very nature of dark energy itself remains unknown. Therefore, from the current scientific perspective, it cannot be concluded that the Big Crunch will inevitably occur. If dark energy behaves like a cosmological constant, it is highly likely that the universe will continue to expand; however, if dark energy actually varies over time, the outlook for the distant future of the universe could also change.
In his book ‘What Is History?’, British historian Edward Carr prompted us to consider that historical events unfold within a relationship between chance and necessity. Applying this to the history of the universe, we can view the existence of humankind as the result of countless intersections of chance and necessity.
The process leading from the first simple life forms to complex multicellular organisms, and ultimately to human beings, must have involved countless chemical bonds, genetic mutations, environmental changes, and natural selection. The fact that we exist today is rooted in the extremely long history of the universe and life, a history that cannot be explained by a single, simple cause.
However, if we summarize the scientific explanations examined so far, one thing is clear. We are connected to the history of the universe, which has been expanding and cooling since the Big Bang; minute density fluctuations in the early universe formed stars and galaxies, and the elements created by stars became the building blocks of planets and living organisms. The minute anisotropies in the cosmic microwave background are linked to the seeds of the vast cosmic structures that have made our existence possible today. In that sense, “I”—the one reading this very article right now—am by no means a being separate from the history of the entire universe.
The more I think about it, the more I realize that our current existence and the nature before our eyes are connected to cosmic conditions from the very distant past. The expansion of the early universe and the distribution of matter, the birth and death of stars, the formation of planets, and the emergence and evolution of life are all interconnected, leading to the existence of human beings today. However, this does not mean there was a “blueprint” from the very beginning designed specifically for the birth of humanity. Rather, what science reveals is that countless physical laws, chance events, and the resulting natural processes have accumulated over a long period of time to create the current universe and humanity.
Ultimately, humans are also just one small event within the history of the “grand universe.” We are not external observers separate from the universe; rather, we are part of the matter and life that the universe has produced over the course of eons. The question of where we came from ultimately connects to the question of how the universe began and evolved, and the question of who we are expands into a question about the history of stars, planets, life, and evolution. Furthermore, the question of where we are going extends beyond the future of individual humans to a question about how the entire universe will change in the future. Although science has not yet found all the answers, based on the facts we do know, we can say that humans are beings created through the interplay of countless coincidences within the inevitability of the universe.

 

About the author

Cam Tien

I love things that are gentle and cute. I love dogs, cats, and flowers because they make me happy. I also enjoy eating and traveling to discover new things. Besides that, I like to lie back, take in the scenery, and relax to enjoy life.