The Light Revolution: Can SPP-Based Optical Integrated Circuits Surpass Semiconductors?

In this blog post, we’ll examine the limitations of electronics—a field long dominated by semiconductors—and explore how optical integrated circuits, which utilize light, and their core technology, SPP, can overcome these limitations.

 

Technology has evolved as the times have changed. In the Stone Age, people used stone, and as time went on, they began crafting daily necessities and weapons from materials that were difficult to work with, such as metal and iron. So, what kind of technological era are we in today? When it comes to electronics, it’s safe to say we are now in the age of semiconductors. Modern humanity can control the flow of electricity on semiconductors; as a result, we can now manipulate electricity as we wish—not only in large-scale applications such as power generation and transmission but also in spaces so small they are invisible to the naked eye. This technology generates substantial profits and serves as the foundation for the massive electrical industry that currently sustains South Korea. However, if we consider that all technologies change over time, we arrive at an intriguing question. When will humanity begin to use a material other than semiconductors, and what might that material be? In fact, from the perspective of controlling “electrons”—the source of electricity—it does not seem easy to move beyond semiconductors. This is because semiconductors are materials that lie between conductors, through which electricity flows easily, and insulators, through which it does not; they are therefore the optimal materials that allow humans to decide, through slight manipulation, whether electricity should flow or be blocked, exactly as they wish. Therefore, I believe that the control of electrons will continue to be based on semiconductors until humans can design the properties of materials as they wish and produce them cheaply. However, if we move beyond the notion that we must control only electrons, we can see that the possibility of new technologies emerging in the not-too-distant future—technologies that surpass semiconductor technology—is very much open. One such possibility is light. In the beginning, when it was said, “Let there be light,” the fastest substance in the world came into being, and thanks to Einstein, modern scientists were able to firmly establish the belief that light is the fastest thing in the world. People began applying light to engineering, and the results were quite successful. One such achievement is the optical communication network that now connects the entire world. This success soon led to efforts to replace electrical engineering on a different scale with optical engineering. In particular, in response to the demand for faster computing speeds, there was a vigorous movement to replace integrated circuits—which require extremely fine manufacturing processes—with optical circuits. However, humanity, in its attempt to control light within very small spaces, encountered a serious obstacle.
Light is commonly understood as a wave, and since waves have a wavelength, light—being a wave—naturally possesses a wavelength as well. An important fact to note here is that a wave can never be confined to a space smaller than its wavelength. Therefore, it is impossible to confine light within a space smaller than its wavelength; specifically, light with a wavelength of 1550 nm—currently used in telecommunications—cannot be concentrated into a space smaller than 1550 nm. While 1550 nm is a relatively short wavelength, this poses a serious problem given that the size scale of the basic building blocks in today’s state-of-the-art semiconductor circuits is merely tens of nanometers. Considering that integration density is so crucial to performance, it is difficult to expect any definite advantage over semiconductor circuits—even if we were to build circuits to control this “bulky” light—given that simply allowing light to pass through requires a significant amount of space. In other words, without resolving these issues, light cannot surpass the dominance of electrons in the modern world.
To address these issues, many scholars have proposed alternatives, one of the most promising being SPP. SPP stands for Surface Plasmon Polariton, a term not widely known to the general public. Put simply, SPPs are light traveling along a metal surface; surprisingly, because light is strongly concentrated near the surface, it can be controlled on a scale comparable to that of semiconductor circuits. How is this possible? It is made possible by the unique electrical properties of metals. Metals are materials that conduct electricity extremely well, a property attributed to the presence of countless “free electrons” within them. Since free electrons are unbound, they move easily in response to external forces, which is why conductors allow electricity to flow so well. The vast number of free electrons in a metal is often likened to a “sea of free electrons,” and this analogy typically provides an intuitive understanding of the properties of metals. However, just as throwing a stone into the sea or an underwater earthquake creates ripples, when an external electrical impulse—in short, high-speed electrons—is “thrown” into a metal, a kind of wave is generated in the sea of free electrons. In other words, waves can form in the sea of free electrons, and as will be explained shortly, these waves are essential for the existence of SPPs. When light penetrates a metal surface, it stirs up the sea of free electrons—much like throwing a stone into the ocean—and waves form on the metal’s surface. These waves propagate along the metal surface, appearing as if the light were confined to the surface. Thanks to the free electrons, light can travel through paths that are just as narrow as those traversed by electrons in conventional circuits. Consequently, optical circuits can achieve a scale similar to that of semiconductor circuits while offering speed advantages, potentially challenging the dominance of semiconductor circuits.
While SPP is noteworthy for overcoming the inherent limitations of light, there are still numerous challenges to be addressed when using SPP to create integrated circuits. A prime example of a problem already pointed out is the relatively high energy loss. This is an unavoidable consequence of the nature of metals; to mitigate energy loss, one must either sacrifice a certain degree of integration density or incur the cost of installing numerous signal amplifiers. However, such limitations are inherent whenever dealing with real-world systems; what is needed now is the design of creative structures and optimization through extensive experimentation. With a bit of luck, these engineering efforts may make it possible to commercialize SPP circuits.

 

About the author

Cam Tien

I love things that are gentle and cute. I love dogs, cats, and flowers because they make me happy. I also enjoy eating and traveling to discover new things. Besides that, I like to lie back, take in the scenery, and relax to enjoy life.