Why do people go to such great lengths to demonstrate their abilities and share information?

In this blog post, we’ll explore why people invest significant time and effort to credibly convey their abilities or information to others, focusing on information asymmetry and signaling theory.

 

Wealthy individuals driving expensive cars and wearing luxury brands; certain members of criminal organizations with numerous tattoos on their arms and bodies; and Super Bowl commercials that can cost over $10 million for just a 30-second spot. At first glance, these examples may seem unrelated, but they share one common thread: they all involve investing significant costs and effort to reveal information about one’s capabilities, resources, affiliations, or products to others. In fact, investment by advertisers has grown to the point where the highest cost for a 30-second commercial during a recent Super Bowl exceeded $10 million. So why do individuals and companies invest so heavily to reveal their capabilities and information?
In interpersonal relationships, individuals often have a relatively good understanding of themselves but lack sufficient knowledge about the other person. The same holds true for the relationship between companies and consumers, and even in communication between individual animals, situations arise where one cannot fully know the other’s condition or capabilities. In a broad sense, this situation can be described as information asymmetry. To reduce information asymmetry, it is necessary to convey information about oneself to the other party. There are various ways to convey information about oneself to others—not only through direct speech but also through behavior, appearance, consumption, investment, and social activities—and these actions can collectively be viewed as sending signals to the other party. However, simply stating, “I am smart,” “I am wealthy,” or “I am trustworthy” is something anyone can do, so such statements alone are unlikely to serve as reliable signals. So, how can one convey information about oneself to others in a more credible way? One method is to send signals in a way that is difficult for individuals lacking those qualities to imitate.
In many animal species, males often possess more colorful feathers, horns, or decorative physical features than females. However, producing and maintaining these features requires energy and nutrients, and in some cases, they may incur survival-related costs—such as hindering movement or making the animal more visible to predators. Therefore, such physical characteristics are likely to function as signals that convey one’s condition or abilities to others. In human society, there are behaviors that can be interpreted in a similar way. For example, in some criminal organizations, getting tattoos covering an entire arm, the entire back, or sometimes large areas of the body requires a significant investment of time, money, and pain. These tattoos go beyond mere decoration; they can serve as symbols that demonstrate membership in or loyalty to the organization, or signal one’s identity to others. One framework that explains this phenomenon—where information is conveyed by bearing costs that are difficult to imitate—is the theory of costly signaling.
The core of costly signaling theory does not simply lie in the idea that “the more expensive the signal, the more credible it is.” What is important is that when someone who does not possess a specific quality or status attempts to mimic the same signal, they must bear relatively higher costs or receive fewer benefits, making it difficult for them to send a false signal. Therefore, under certain conditions, costs and benefits vary depending on the signaler’s actual status, and it is this difference that helps maintain the signal’s credibility. In modern signaling theory, it has also been pointed out that the absolute cost actually incurred is neither strictly necessary nor sufficient on its own to guarantee the honesty of a signal. Cost-signaling theory is not the sole explanation for all the reasons why altruistic behavior emerges in humans. This is because altruistic behavior is related to various factors, such as kin selection, reciprocity, reputation, and cooperative relationships. However, the cost signaling theory offers an important perspective in explaining how the act of investing time, resources, and effort to help others can convey one’s abilities, resources, willingness to cooperate, and trustworthiness to the other party, thereby influencing the acquisition of a good reputation or cooperative partners. Therefore, this theory remains one of the useful explanatory frameworks for understanding why humans and animals sometimes go to considerable lengths to reveal their abilities and information.

 

About the author

Cam Tien

I love things that are gentle and cute. I love dogs, cats, and flowers because they make me happy. I also enjoy eating and traveling to discover new things. Besides that, I like to lie back, take in the scenery, and relax to enjoy life.