In this blog post, we’ll examine how competition over the world’s limited resources leads to war, political conflict, labor exploitation, environmental pollution, and economic inequality, and consider what efforts are needed to secure resources while minimizing these negative consequences.
The Dark Side of the Resource War
The world is engaged in fierce competition to secure limited resources. A stable supply of energy and critical minerals has now transcended mere economic concerns to become a matter of national security and industrial competitiveness. Recently, the stability of supply chains—not only for oil and natural gas but also for critical minerals such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, graphite, rare earth elements, and copper—has become a major issue in international politics. This is because if production or refining processes become overly concentrated in a specific country, the entire industry could be affected in the event of export restrictions or supply disruptions.
In such circumstances, competition over resources can lead to new forms of geopolitical conflict. China’s export controls on rare earth elements and the conflict between Russia and Europe over natural gas supplies are examples that demonstrate just how powerful a tool resources can be in international politics. Since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Europe’s dependence on Russian natural gas has significantly decreased, and the European Union is pursuing policies aimed at phasing out Russian gas.
While many countries are focusing their efforts on new energy technologies—such as solar, wind, hydrogen, bioenergy, and electric vehicles—to address the energy crisis and climate change, this does not mean that traditional resources have lost their importance. On the contrary, as the energy transition progresses, the importance of new resources is growing. This is because a variety of critical minerals are needed to manufacture electric vehicle batteries, power grids, and renewable energy infrastructure. Consequently, today’s competition for resources has expanded in scope—from a race to secure oil and gas to a race to secure critical minerals and the supply chains that process them.
However, the longer this situation persists, the more intense the competition for resources may become, and in some cases, there is a risk that measures sacrificing human lives and the environment will be employed. We might view these issues as matters far removed from our own lives and remain indifferent. However, many South Korean companies are also developing or securing energy and mineral resources overseas, and political instability, armed conflicts, and institutional risks in resource-development regions can directly impact these companies and their supply chains. Since South Korea is highly dependent on energy imports and has an industrial structure that consumes large amounts of energy, ensuring a stable supply of resources and energy is a particularly critical challenge.
While everyone recognizes the precious value of resources, people often fail to give sufficient thought to the risks involved in extracting them, the people who are sacrificed in the process, and who ultimately reaps the benefits and bears the costs of resource development. Competition over resources creates a complex web of conflicting interests not only between nations but also within a single country—among the government, corporations, local communities, and workers. It is now necessary to examine both the wealth generated by resources and the hidden dangers behind them, as well as the political and social situations in which resource-rich nations find themselves.
In the Places Where Resources Are Extracted
Resources That Invite Bloodshed and Ignorance
Just because a country is rich in resources does not necessarily mean that all its citizens enjoy a prosperous life. On the contrary, an economic structure that relies excessively on resources can sometimes exacerbate corruption and political conflict, hinder industrial diversification, and make long-term economic growth difficult. This phenomenon is often referred to as the “resource curse.”
Nigeria, in Africa, has long been cited as a prime example of a country where the benefits and costs of resource development have not been distributed equitably, despite its abundant oil reserves. While the oil industry serves as a vital foundation for the national economy, oil-producing regions have repeatedly faced environmental pollution, community conflicts, armed group activities, and attacks and theft targeting oil facilities. However, it is inaccurate to describe Nigeria’s situation simply as “a country that has become poor because it has too much oil.” This is because the situation is the result of a complex interplay of factors, including political institutions, administrative capacity, corruption, interregional inequality, public safety issues, and high dependence on the oil industry.
Due to a severe shortage of refining capacity in the past, Nigeria’s oil industry long maintained a structure in which it produced crude oil but had to import petroleum products for domestic use. However, the situation is changing as large-scale refining facilities come online. In particular, since the launch of these major refineries, Nigeria’s production and export of petroleum products have increased, while its reliance on imports has decreased. Therefore, when analyzing Nigeria, it is necessary to distinguish between the past issues of insufficient refining capacity and fuel imports and the current situation.
That said, conflicts over resources have not disappeared. If the benefits of resource development are not fairly distributed to the state and local communities, and if environmental damage is concentrated in specific regions, residents’ dissatisfaction may grow. While resources can serve as the driving force of a national economy, if mismanaged, they can instead become a factor that exacerbates political instability and social conflict.
The Democratic Republic of the Congo also possesses vast natural resources but is a country that has long suffered from severe political instability and armed conflict. In the eastern region, in particular, conflict between armed groups and government forces persists, and the instability in this region is having a significant impact on residents’ lives and resource development. The Democratic Republic of the Congo is rich in key minerals such as cobalt and copper, but this abundance of resources does not directly translate into improved living standards for the entire population. The World Bank also assesses that, despite its abundant natural resources, many citizens are unable to fully enjoy the benefits of these resources due to prolonged conflict and political instability.
In particular, in resource-rich regions, when armed groups seize control of mines and transportation routes or secure funding through resource trade, these resources can become a source of funding that perpetuates conflict rather than a means to end it. For this reason, the international community is increasingly focusing on efforts to track the origins and trade routes of minerals and strengthen due diligence on supply chains to ensure that resources are not linked to armed conflict. Recently, as the supply chains for critical minerals have emerged as issues of energy and economic security, the importance of systems and technologies for tracking where minerals are produced and the routes they take to reach consumers has also grown.
Thus, in resource-rich countries, resources—which should serve as the driving force of the economy—can instead become factors that fuel social conflict and political instability. The reality is that the international community, too, needs these resources and therefore finds it difficult to completely turn its back on resources produced in conflict zones. Ultimately, the key issue is not simply whether or not to secure resources, but rather to responsibly manage the entire supply chain to ensure that resources are not traded in ways that perpetuate conflict and human rights violations.
Children Subjected to Labor Exploitation
In regions rich in mineral resources, concerns about small-scale and informal mining operations conducted under poor conditions, as well as child labor, have long been raised. According to the International Labor Organization, child labor is particularly prevalent in small-scale and informal mining operations; children working in mines and quarries not only lose educational opportunities but are also exposed to serious safety and health risks, such as carrying heavy loads or operating dangerous equipment.
Exposure to hazardous substances like mercury during the extraction of gold or other minerals is also a concern. In particular, some small-scale gold mines still use mercury to extract gold. Mercury can have serious effects on the nervous system and kidneys; not only are miners directly exposed, but mercury released during the mining process can spread into the surrounding environment, causing harm to local communities as well. Therefore, labor issues in mining are not merely a matter of wages or working hours but require consideration of workers’ health, the surrounding environment, and the safety of local communities.
These issues also arise in the supply chains of critical minerals such as cobalt. In the cobalt supply chain of the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the link between small-scale and artisanal mines and child labor has been consistently highlighted internationally. The International Labor Organization (ILO) has recently emphasized that governments, companies, and international organizations must collaborate on supply chain due diligence, prevention, and redress to resolve this issue.
The international community, including the ILO, is establishing labor standards to ensure that children do not work in environments that could harm their health, and companies must also verify production sites and trade routes and strengthen due diligence to prevent child labor from occurring in their supply chains. However, the mere existence of laws and regulations does not automatically eliminate problems on the ground. This is because structural issues—such as poverty, lack of educational opportunities, regional instability, and the informal labor market—must also be addressed.
The resources we cherish and value must not be produced in a way that tramples on the dignified lives of others. This is why we must pay attention to where and how the minerals used in automobiles, electronics, batteries, and various high-tech devices are produced. Although the end consumers of these resources cannot directly witness what happens in the mines, they cannot completely turn a blind eye to the human rights and environmental issues that arise during the production process.
Resource Development That Pollutes the Earth
Groundwater Contamination Caused by Shale Gas and Hazardous Chemicals
Shale gas refers to unconventional natural gas trapped in rock formations such as shale layers. Hydraulic fracturing, a method widely used to extract shale gas from underground, involves injecting a fluid mixture of water, sand, and various additives into rock formations at high pressure to create fractures, allowing gas to flow through them. Proppants, such as sand, prevent the created fractures from closing again, thereby maintaining the flow of gas. The hydraulic fracturing process requires a significant amount of water, and some of the water injected underground is recovered to the surface for treatment and reuse, or managed as wastewater. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) divides the water cycle of hydraulic fracturing into several stages, including water withdrawal, chemical mixing, underground injection, recovery and treatment, and wastewater treatment and reuse.
One of the key controversies surrounding hydraulic fracturing is the safety of groundwater and drinking water. While it cannot be concluded that hydraulic fracturing itself always contaminates groundwater, there is a possibility of contamination occurring through various pathways, including well construction and operation, wastewater treatment, surface runoff, and existing fractures or faults. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has presented scientific evidence showing that activities related to hydraulic fracturing can affect drinking water resources under certain conditions, and has also examined under what conditions such impacts may become more frequent or severe.
In the past, significant public controversy arose in some parts of the United States after reports emerged that, following gas development involving hydraulic fracturing, methane was detected in well water or that the water could be set on fire. However, these phenomena should not be simply attributed to chemicals used in the fracking process or the direct influx of underground gas. Methane in groundwater may occur naturally, and to identify the cause of contamination, a comprehensive investigation of geological characteristics, well conditions, drilling processes, and water quality data is necessary. In fact, when evaluating the relationship between fracking and drinking water, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency analyzed the impacts by distinguishing between various pathways and conditions.
The fluids used in hydraulic fracturing may contain various additives, and the water used may carry materials from the rock formations as it is recovered from underground and brought to the surface. Therefore, it is crucial not merely to emphasize the fact that chemicals are used, but to continuously verify which substances are used and at what concentrations, how the recovered water is treated, and whether the safety of the wells and rock formations is properly managed.
Furthermore, since shale gas development requires significant amounts of water, conflicts over water resource use may arise in water-scarce regions. This is because, depending on local water resource conditions, securing the water needed for development may compete with water sources such as rivers, groundwater, agricultural water, and domestic water supplies for local communities. Therefore, shale gas development should not be evaluated solely based on energy production; water usage, wastewater treatment, and ecological impacts must also be taken into account.
Ultimately, shale gas is a resource that can expand energy supply, but it is also one that requires the management of environmental risks during the development process. To ensure that efficient resource use and environmental protection do not conflict, regulations—such as ensuring well safety, monitoring water quality, treating wastewater, and managing chemicals—must be implemented in tandem.
Ecological Destruction Caused by Oil Spills
As offshore oil field development has expanded, it has become clear that a large-scale accident could result in extremely widespread damage. A prime example is the Deepwater Horizon accident in the Gulf of Mexico. That accident, which occurred at an offshore well, resulted in a massive crude oil spill and went down in history as one of the largest offshore oil spills in U.S. history. Approximately 134 million gallons of crude oil were spilled, resulting in the loss of 11 workers’ lives and injuries to 17 others.
This accident caused damage to a wide variety of organisms and habitats in the Gulf of Mexico, including fish, benthic organisms, coastal ecosystems, seabirds, sea turtles, and marine mammals. The damage went far beyond oil simply floating on the surface of the water. As the oil affected ecosystems in coastal wetlands, beaches, and both shallow and deep waters, it disrupted the food chain and habitats, and impacted local economic activities such as fishing and tourism. Since the accident, U.S. agencies, including NOAA, have been conducting long-term investigations into the damage to natural resources and carrying out ecosystem restoration efforts.
The legal liabilities and restoration costs surrounding BP, the company responsible for the accident, were also enormous. The total value of the settlements reached between the U.S. government, several Gulf Coast states, and BP amounted to $20.8 billion, which included costs for natural resource damage and restoration. The amount allocated for natural resource restoration reached up to $8.8 billion.
However, environmental damage cannot be fully quantified by monetary value alone. Fishermen and tourism workers in oil-contaminated areas may temporarily lose their livelihoods, and it may take a long time for ecosystems to recover. Therefore, when calculating the economic benefits of resource development, one must also consider who will bear the costs in the event of an accident, what ecological damage will occur, and how long local communities will be affected.
Even after the Deepwater Horizon accident, long-term recovery efforts continue in the Gulf of Mexico. The process of restoring natural resources includes habitat restoration, water quality improvement, the recovery of fish and wildlife, the protection of coastal and marine ecosystems, and the restoration of recreational spaces used by residents. This demonstrates that the damage caused by a large-scale resource development accident does not end immediately after the incident but can persist for decades.
Negative Economic and Political Impacts of Resource Exploitation
Bioenergy Driving Up Grain Prices
Bioenergy is one of the key energy sources that can help reduce fossil fuel use and lower greenhouse gas emissions. However, when crops suitable for food are used on a large scale to produce biofuels, the dilemma of “food versus fuel” can arise. Particularly in situations where food prices are already high or where low-income groups have limited access to food, increased demand for crops used as fuel is likely to strain food security.
In the past, when international grain prices spiked, the expansion of biofuels was sometimes cited as one factor contributing to the rise in food prices. However, grain prices are not determined by biofuel demand alone. Various factors interact, including climate, drought, production levels, stockpiles, international oil prices, trade policies, exchange rates, logistics costs, and demand for animal feed. Therefore, rather than simplistically claiming that the expansion of bioenergy directly causes global hunger, it is more accurate to examine how competition for land and resources between food crops and fuel crops might affect food security.
In particular, for crops that can be used for both food and fuel—such as corn and vegetable oils—the food and fuel markets are likely to influence each other as energy demand increases. Conversely, advances in technologies that utilize waste cooking oil, agricultural and forestry byproducts, and non-edible biomass can reduce direct competition between food and fuel. Therefore, rather than unconditionally expanding or, conversely, unconditionally rejecting bioenergy, we must comprehensively evaluate which raw materials are used, how much land and water are consumed, and how much greenhouse gas emissions are actually reduced.
The expansion of bioenergy raises an important question for us: Are we sacrificing too much of the land and resources needed for food production in the process of securing energy for automobiles and industry? For the energy transition to be truly sustainable, it must not stop at simply replacing fossil fuels with other fuels. It must be carried out in a way that takes food security, ecosystems, and the livelihoods of local communities into account.
Resources as Political Tools
Today, resource-rich nations often utilize their resources not only as economic tools but also as political ones. In particular, resources that are difficult to replace—such as oil and natural gas—can significantly influence diplomatic relations between supplier and consumer nations. Recently, rare earth elements and critical minerals have also begun to take on similar characteristics. This is because production and refining processes are concentrated in specific countries, meaning that export restrictions or supply disruptions can directly impact the industries and security of other nations.
Venezuela is a prime example of a country that has long utilized its oil resources as a key tool in diplomacy and domestic politics. In the past, the Hugo Chávez administration used oil resources as the foundation for domestic welfare policies and foreign policy, emphasizing political solidarity in Latin America to counter U.S. influence. However, it is not appropriate to describe Venezuela’s current situation solely in terms of Chávez’s personal policies. Even after Chávez’s death, Venezuela’s oil-dependent economy and political conflicts have persisted, and various factors—such as the economic crisis and international sanctions—continue to affect the country’s oil industry and economy.
The relationship between Russia and Europe regarding natural gas also demonstrates that resources can serve as political tools. Russia has long been a key supplier of natural gas to Europe, but Europe’s dependence on Russian gas has significantly decreased since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Changes in the natural gas supply chain have gone beyond mere shifts in energy trade, affecting European foreign policy, energy security policy, and energy costs for both industry and households. Currently, Europe is moving toward reducing its dependence on Russian gas and diversifying its supply sources.
In the Middle East, too, oil and natural gas have long been key elements of international politics. This is because attacks on oil production facilities and transportation routes can affect not only the targeted country but also the entire international energy market. In the past, repeated attacks targeting refineries, oil pipelines, and oil tankers further strengthened the link between resources and security.
It is also an overly simplistic interpretation to explain the U.S. invasion of Iraq solely in terms of oil. The Iraq War involved a complex interplay of various factors, including the issue of weapons of mass destruction, terrorism and national security, and the political order in the Middle East. However, it is clear that this serves as a case study for examining the relationship between resources and international politics, given that global oil supply and the strategic importance of the Middle East played a significant role in shaping the policy decisions of the United States and the international community.
As such, the world competes over resources and, at times, even engages in direct conflict over them. While oil and gas were at the center of this competition in the past, today the scope of competition has expanded to include critical minerals necessary for the energy transition. The International Energy Agency points out that the production and refining of critical minerals are concentrated in a small number of countries, which could increase the vulnerability of supply chains. In particular, when a specific country accounts for a large share of mineral refining and processing, there may be a shortage of materials actually needed by industry, even if production at the mines is sufficient.
Does this mean that resource-poor countries are inevitably at the mercy of resource-rich nations or major powers? Not necessarily. Resource-importing countries can reduce their dependence on specific nations by diversifying their supply sources, expanding strategic reserves, and developing recycling and alternative technologies. South Korea, too, is implementing policies to diversify its supply chains for critical minerals and reduce its dependence on specific countries. This demonstrates that resource security is evolving from a matter of simply securing large quantities of resources from abroad to one of enhancing the resilience of the entire supply chain.
Of course, if competition for resources becomes excessively fierce, there is a possibility that smaller nations or resource-poor countries could face political and economic pressure. Conversely, resource-rich nations that overuse their resources as political weapons risk losing the trust of the international community in the long run or prompting other countries to seek alternative sources. Therefore, international cooperation, supply chain diversification, fair trade, and transparent resource development are essential to ensure that competition over resources does not lead solely to war and conflict.
Resources: Our Stance
Resources, in and of themselves, hold immense value. Oil and natural gas have powered industry and transportation, while minerals such as iron and copper have laid the foundation for civilization. Today, critical minerals such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, and rare earth elements are used in batteries, power grids, electric vehicles, advanced electronic devices, and various energy technologies. The value of resources remains significant; in fact, as technology advances, the importance of new resources continues to grow.
However, having examined the dark side of resources thus far, we need to reconsider their value as well. To what extent should we tolerate the dark shadow cast by resources in order to secure them? Even if securing resources is crucial for a nation’s survival and economic growth, we must ask whether methods that sacrifice the lives of people in other countries or local communities and destroy the environment are truly sustainable.
Securing a stable supply of resources remains a critical issue for national survival and the economy. In particular, countries like South Korea—which rely heavily on energy imports and where energy consumption accounts for a large share of industrial activity—can be significantly affected by changes in the international energy market and instability in resource supply chains. Since South Korea is highly dependent on foreign sources for key energy resources such as crude oil and natural gas, it is crucial to manage supply chains stably and diversify energy sources. At the same time, we need to achieve both energy security and carbon reduction by utilizing various means, such as renewable energy, improved energy efficiency, low-carbon energy sources like nuclear power, and hydrogen and storage technologies.
However, we cannot continue to pursue survival and economic gain indefinitely while ignoring the dark side of resource extraction discussed earlier. If environmental damage, human rights violations, and conflicts within local communities continue to accumulate, they will ultimately result in even greater social costs. Even if the profits from resource development are substantial in the short term, the actual costs can be much higher when we factor in the expenses of environmental restoration, social conflicts, and the harm caused by human rights violations that arise during the process.
The resources available to us are limited, and the global competition for resources continues. Securing independent resource development and stable supply chains is a critical task for national survival and industrial competitiveness. However, securing resources by prioritizing only our own interests cannot be considered the right path for the future. Resource security and sustainability are not conflicting values but goals that must be pursued together.
We must actively support the peaceful resolution of conflicts and civil wars at the international level to prevent bloodshed over resources, and we must manage supply chains with care to ensure that children and workers are not exploited during the resource development process. Companies, too, must go beyond simply securing a stable supply of resources; they must verify where and how minerals and energy are produced and strengthen due diligence regarding human rights and the environment. This is why traceability and responsible sourcing in critical mineral supply chains have recently become increasingly important.
Furthermore, the international community must strengthen the safety and environmental protection standards required during resource development and establish systems to ensure that companies and governments assume appropriate responsibility in the event of an accident. Systems must also be put in place to prevent water and air pollution and ecosystem destruction that may occur during resource development, as well as to remediate damage that has already occurred. Ensuring the stability of energy and mineral supply chains while protecting the environment and human rights is what constitutes true resource security.
The international community must also cooperate to ensure that resource nationalism and the weaponization of resources are not used in ways that escalate conflicts. That said, we must not deny resource-rich nations the right to manage their own resources and determine their resource development policies. What is important is to recognize the legitimate interests of each country regarding resources while ensuring international rules and transparency, and to prevent the benefits of resources from being concentrated solely in the hands of a few governments or corporations.
Today, resources are not merely materials extracted from the ground for use. Resources are a complex issue that connects a nation’s economy and industry, international politics, the environment, human rights, and our daily lives. If we consider the journey that a single drop of oil or a single mineral takes to reach us, we can gain a deeper understanding of the true value of resources. Resources are undoubtedly treasures necessary for humanity, but if we sacrifice the lives of others and the Earth’s environment to obtain them, those treasures may ultimately become a curse for us all. Just as important as securing resources is collectively considering how we obtain them, with whom and how we share them, and what kind of environment we will leave for future generations.