Why does appropriate technology sometimes succeed and sometimes fail in developing countries?

In this blog post, we’ll examine the meaning of appropriate technology and compare the cases of PET bottle solar lamps and PlayPumps—both of which have been implemented in developing countries—to identify the conditions necessary for appropriate technology to succeed.

 

Modern technology is advancing faster than ever before and is expected to develop at an even faster pace in the future. Media and computers have already become deeply embedded in our lives, and artificial intelligence and robotics have advanced to the point of mimicking human language and behavior. However, the rapid advancement of science and technology has created a gap in access to its benefits within human society, leading to criticism that technology is no longer “technology for people” but rather “technology for technology’s sake.” Appropriate technology emerged from technical efforts to bridge this gap between society and science and technology and fill the resulting void, as well as from efforts to find a balance in science and technology.
What is appropriate technology? An important starting point for appropriate technology can be found in the concept of “intermediate technology” proposed by the British economist Ernst Friedrich Schumacher, who offered an alternative to the adverse effects of science and technology. Schumacher’s “intermediate technology” is rooted in the local communities where people live; it is affordable enough for widespread use; minimizes the waste of scarce resources; utilizes decentralized energy sources; employs relatively simple technologies and locally available materials; and aims to create jobs. This perspective continues to serve as a key principle of appropriate technology today, which takes into account local environmental, resource, and social conditions.
In other words, the “intermediate technology” Schumacher referred to means technology that helps even those who have not fully benefited from development to improve their basic quality of life. To correct the negative connotations associated with the term “intermediate technology,” the term “appropriate technology” began to be widely used; appropriate technology has expanded in meaning beyond technology intended for specific developing countries to encompass technology that addresses the needs of marginalized groups. Furthermore, appropriate technology has come to signify technology developed with consideration for the cultural, political, and environmental aspects of a community. Such appropriate technology helps communities that have not fully benefited from modern science and technology to enjoy its benefits. Among these efforts, support and initiatives for developing countries are particularly significant. Various nations, international organizations, corporations, and civil society have strived to improve living conditions and foster self-reliance in developing countries through the use of appropriate technology. However, these appropriate technology initiatives do not always succeed as ideally envisioned. While many attempts at appropriate technology have succeeded in providing a significant turning point for residents of developing countries, there are also numerous cases where projects have failed or fallen short of expectations because local needs and conditions were not sufficiently taken into account. Let’s examine both the success stories and failures of appropriate technology applied in developing countries to identify the key factors necessary for it to yield successful results.
There are countless examples of successfully utilized appropriate technologies, including the LifeStraw—which helps filter bacteria and parasites from contaminated water so it is safe to drink without electricity—and the Hippo Water Roller, which reduces the burden of having to travel long distances back and forth to fetch water. LifeStraw currently offers products capable of treating up to approximately 4,000 liters of water per personal filter; it uses a fine membrane to filter out bacteria and certain parasites. The Hippo Water Roller is designed to hold up to 90 liters of water in a barrel that can be rolled along the ground, aiming to reduce the physical strain and time spent by women and children who previously had to carry water on their heads.
Among these, the “Solar Bottle Bulb” in the Philippines stands out as a prime example of successful appropriate technology implemented in developing countries. The Solar Bottle Bulb is a very simple yet groundbreaking technology that provides light to some Filipino households that must live in dark interiors even during the day. The basic method involves installing a transparent plastic bottle filled with water and a small amount of bleach on the roof. Sunlight entering from above the roof is refracted and diffused as it passes through the PET bottle filled with water, illuminating the interior space beneath the roof. Unlike conventional solar lights, the basic Solar Bottle Bulb is not a device that generates electricity but rather one that diffuses sunlight entering during the day throughout the entire interior. It is known to produce a level of brightness equivalent to a 55–60-watt light bulb on a clear day.
The PET bottle solar lamp, which improved the quality of life for local residents in the Philippines through such a simple manufacturing method, garnered significant international attention and subsequently spread beyond the Philippines to various other countries. Today, “Liter of Light” has evolved beyond simply creating light from PET bottles; it now educates local residents, cooperatives, and volunteers on solar lighting technology and supports them in manufacturing and installing the lamps locally. In other words, the initiative has evolved beyond merely distributing simple devices to transferring technical knowledge and production methods to local residents, empowering them to utilize and disseminate the technology on their own.
While some appropriate technologies, such as the PET bottle solar lamp, garnered attention as creative innovations in the media, others have revealed serious limitations during large-scale deployment. One such example is the PlayPump. The PlayPump is a system that uses the force generated by children turning a rotating playground structure to draw up groundwater and store it in a water tank. It was widely praised as a groundbreaking solution that could reduce the burden on children and women in Africa who previously had to walk long distances to fetch water. Many people viewed it as an appropriate technology that simultaneously solved the problems of play and drinking water, as children could play on the merry-go-round while supplying water. Although large-scale deployment and sponsorship did take place, various issues arose on the ground depending on the region, including utilization rates, maintenance, costs, and the suitability of installation sites. Subsequently, large-scale expansion was halted, and today, it is used only in limited settings where conditions are suitable, such as schools.
Both the PET bottle solar lamp and the PlayPump received capital and support based on creative ideas and external interest, and they appeared to be appropriate technologies capable of providing clear benefits to local residents. However, the two technologies yielded different outcomes. So, what factors caused the PET bottle solar lamp and the PlayPump to take completely different paths?
First, there is a difference in the understanding of the local residents—the intended beneficiaries of appropriate technology. The PET bottle solar lamp, which is regarded as a successful example of appropriate technology, was developed based on an understanding of the local residents’ living conditions and needs. During its rollout in the Philippines, the technology was applied in a way that took local residents’ needs into account, and an approach was adopted that sought to find answers on-site regarding what people actually needed. In contrast, during the large-scale rollout of the PlayPump, critics argued that the focus was on the symbolic significance of appropriate technology and the promotion of a large-scale project rather than on the people who would actually use the technology. When the focus is on the value of the technology and capital-driven business ventures rather than on the lives and needs of the people using appropriate technology, the technology—no matter how creative—will struggle to function properly on the ground.
Consequently, the PlayPump project faced criticism for prioritizing media coverage and publicity aimed at securing sponsorships and large-scale distribution over genuine consideration for local residents. Ultimately, in some areas, installations proceeded before sufficient consensus had been reached with local residents. Interviews with local residents at the time included comments such as the following: “This playground equipment is too heavy for women to turn. Older people, in particular, cannot turn it without help from others. The hand pump we used before was much easier. And I don’t understand why there was no consultation with us at all regarding the replacement of the pump. The pump just showed up here.” As such, the PlayPump’s technology provider failed to communicate sufficiently with the local residents who would actually be using the pump. Some residents had never wanted a PlayPump in the first place, and the technology provider made insufficient efforts to understand their lifestyles and needs. This lack of communication and understanding of the local residents was one of the key reasons why the PlayPump was not utilized properly in the field.
When the PlayPump was designed, the technology provider assumed that African children would use the play equipment consistently. However, this assumption did not fully reflect the living conditions and usage patterns in all regions. In actual field settings, children sometimes did not use the play equipment as much as expected, and situations arose where adults—particularly women—who needed water had to operate the rotary pump to obtain it. As a result, some areas reported that obtaining water had become more difficult than with traditional hand pumps. Appropriate technology requires more than simply verifying that the technology itself functions; it must also consider how actual users will utilize the technology and how it will integrate with their existing lifestyles. The PlayPump case study demonstrates precisely how crucial it is to understand the communication patterns and daily routines of technology users.
Another difference between the two cases lies in sustainability. Sustainability can be further divided into two aspects: sustainability in terms of cost and resources, and sustainability in terms of technology. First, let’s examine sustainability in terms of cost and resources. Appropriate technology in developing countries is often designed for people with limited resources for daily living. Therefore, it must be inexpensive, and the materials used in the technology should, whenever possible, be locally sourced; only then can it be considered highly sustainable in terms of cost and resources.
Based on this, when examining the two case studies, the PET bottle solar lamp is relatively well-suited for ensuring sustainability, whereas the PlayPump faced significant challenges in terms of cost and maintenance during large-scale deployment. The PET bottle solar lamp uses relatively simple materials, such as water, a small amount of bleach, discarded PET bottles, and metal plates and sealants for mounting it to a roof. Since most of the materials can be sourced locally and the manufacturing process is relatively simple, local residents are highly likely to produce and maintain them themselves. In contrast, the PlayPump is a relatively large-scale water supply system that requires various components—such as drilling for groundwater, a pump, a rotating playground structure, piping, and a water tank. Consequently, external capital and specialized technical support are often required from the initial installation stage, and even after installation, costs and organizational resources are needed for maintenance and repairs. When it is difficult to maintain the technology using only local residents’ capital, dependence on external funding and support increases; furthermore, the technology’s sustainability may be affected if external economic conditions or support policies change. Considering these differences in terms of costs and resources, the PET bottle solar lamp was well-positioned for sustained use, whereas the PlayPump faced challenges that made success difficult without a secure, ongoing management system.
Next is technological sustainability. Technological sustainability refers to whether users can master the technology without specialized knowledge and whether local residents can understand its underlying principles. In other words, if the technology is easy to learn and its principles are easy to understand, it can be considered highly sustainable from a technological perspective; conversely, technologies that require specialized knowledge and long-term training may be difficult for local residents to maintain on their own, potentially reducing their sustainability. From the perspective of this technical sustainability, the PET bottle solar lamp has the advantage of being relatively easy to make. Once one learns how to process metal sheets and securely fasten the PET bottle, it can be made by hand, and the principle of using water to refract and diffuse sunlight is also easy to understand. Furthermore, the current “Liter of Light” initiative emphasizes technology transfer by not only delivering finished devices but also training local residents, cooperatives, and volunteers in how to build and install them. In contrast, the PlayPump requires relatively specialized skills—such as groundwater development, pump installation, and mechanical maintenance—so local residents may find it difficult to repair the device on their own without a consistent support system.
Since the PlayPump is a facility that can be used for a long time once installed, one might think that residents do not need to learn the technology and principles themselves. However, in order to repair the device when it breaks down, it is necessary to understand its basic operating principles and maintenance methods. In the case of appropriate technologies with low sustainability, residents find it difficult to resolve problems on their own when they arise and are forced to rely on technology providers or outside companies. In fact, breakdowns and maintenance issues emerged as major concerns during the initial large-scale rollout of PlayPumps. At the time, one resident said, “The PlayPump didn’t supply any water for six months. The billboard project—part of the revenue model for breakdown repairs that Field had promoted—isn’t being implemented here. Even when we request repairs or send letters, we receive no response.” A local water resources official at the time also pointed out that repairs took a long time when the pumps broke down, leading to a loss of trust among residents. As such, if local residents find it difficult to resolve equipment malfunctions on their own and external support is not readily available, they may eventually lose the will to use the equipment. Therefore, the PlayPump case demonstrates that the sustainability of appropriate technology can only be ensured by considering not only technical aspects but also maintenance systems and the technical capabilities of local residents.
We have examined two cases where appropriate technology applied in developing countries yielded diametrically opposed results. The examples of the plastic bottle solar lamp and the PlayPump demonstrate that appropriate technology can only be successful when there is sufficient communication and consensus regarding the technology between the technology provider and local residents, and when sustainability is ensured from both a cost and technical perspective. Of course, the PlayPump has not failed in every region; it is still in use today in places such as schools—where there is sufficient use by children and where groundwater and maintenance conditions are adequate. Therefore, what matters is not whether a specific technology is inherently successful or unsuccessful, but whether it is thoroughly evaluated to ensure it is suitable for the location and the conditions of its users.
In summary, for appropriate technology to be successfully applied in developing countries, it is ultimately essential for technology providers to have a thorough understanding of the people who will benefit from it. This understanding of the recipients of appropriate technology can be achieved more effectively when the technology provider’s objectives for development align with the original purpose of appropriate technology. If technology providers pursue the original purpose of appropriate technology—that is, to serve those marginalized by rapidly advancing technology—the likelihood of this alignment of objectives increases, and interaction with local residents will naturally occur to understand the lives and needs of marginalized people. Furthermore, such interaction can lead to the discovery of on-site problems that the technology provider had not anticipated and to a process of adapting the technology to local conditions.
It is not easy to maintain an altruistic sense of purpose in modern capitalist society. Even in the process of developing and providing appropriate technology, situations may arise where promoting the technology, attracting investment, or focusing on the scale and performance of the project take precedence over the needs of the people who actually use the technology. Therefore, developers and providers of appropriate technology must constantly remind themselves of what the beneficiaries truly need and that the intended recipients of appropriate technology are the local residents, not the providers themselves. If developers and providers communicate sufficiently with local residents, adapt the technology to the local living environment, resources, and culture, and establish the necessary capacity-building and management systems to ensure residents can maintain the technology and resolve issues even after installation, they can at least minimize failures such as those that occurred during the initial large-scale rollout of the PlayPump. Ultimately, the success of appropriate technology does not depend on how advanced or creative the technology is, but on how effectively it enables the people who actually need it to use it sustainably.

 

About the author

Cam Tien

I love things that are gentle and cute. I love dogs, cats, and flowers because they make me happy. I also enjoy eating and traveling to discover new things. Besides that, I like to lie back, take in the scenery, and relax to enjoy life.