In this blog post, I’ll explore how identity is formed and can clash between my real-world self and my virtual self through the movies ‘The Matrix’ and ‘Total Recall’, as well as online games and today’s virtual reality.
The movie ‘The Matrix’, widely known for its iconic bullet-dodging scene, is a familiar work to many. ‘The Matrix’ is set in a world where machines equipped with artificial intelligence dominate humanity, and most people live in a virtual reality without even realizing it. Within the virtual world of the Matrix, most people go about their lives believing they are seeing the real world. The protagonist, Neo, is also initially unaware that the world he inhabits is a virtual one. In reality, he lives as a programmer named Thomas Anderson while engaging in hacking activities under the alias Neo. One day, Neo comes into contact with Morpheus, who knows the true nature of the Matrix, and, armed with clues about the Matrix from him, begins to uncover the truth behind the world he believed to be real. Ultimately, Neo is confronted with the shocking truth that the world he has always believed to be real is not, in fact, reality.
Watching movies like ‘The Matrix’ or ‘Total Recall’ can lead one to wonder whether the reality in which humans currently live might also be a virtual world created by someone else. It’s the idea that perhaps humans, like the people in ‘The Matrix’, are living within a vast virtual reality without realizing its true nature. However, proving or disproving this hypothesis is an extremely difficult task. The virtual reality that humans create and use today is fundamentally different in nature from the world depicted in the movie ‘The Matrix’. The people in ‘The Matrix’ are unaware that the world they live in is a virtual one. Therefore, to them, the Matrix is not just one of many worlds, but the only world they know—and thus, reality itself. In contrast, today’s virtual reality is a space created by humans using technology, and users generally access it while being aware that it is an artificially constructed environment. Consequently, a person can live in the real world while simultaneously participating in multiple virtual spaces, experiencing different roles or relationships in each one. So, how is a person’s identity formed when they live in different ways in the real world and in multiple virtual worlds? Human identity and the self are not formed solely within the individual; they are shaped by the individual’s society, relationships with others, and diverse experiences. Consequently, if a person moves between multiple worlds with different rules and interpersonal dynamics, the aspects of their identity revealed in each space may differ. The problem is that these various aspects may not always naturally integrate into a single, cohesive identity.
Today, virtual reality (VR) is no longer merely a technology found in science fiction novels or movies. Virtual reality and immersive technologies are actually being utilized in various fields—including gaming and entertainment, as well as education and training, healthcare and rehabilitation, design, and simulation—and are also being researched in the field of medical education as a means to simulate clinical situations and conduct repetitive training. One of the examples that comes to mind relatively easily when thinking about these virtual worlds is online gaming. Strictly speaking, not all online games use virtual reality technology, but in that they allow users to interact with other players and engage in activities through characters within a digital space governed by rules different from those of the real world, they serve as a prime example for considering identity in a virtual world. Today’s online games have evolved beyond simply completing predetermined missions and earning points into complex digital spaces featuring diverse rules, social relationships, and economic elements. In some games, the value of in-game currency or items is even linked to real-world economic activity. Users create their own characters or avatars within these online games and, through them, collaborate with or compete against other players’ characters, engage in conversation, and form relationships. From this perspective, a character can serve as a means of expressing another “self” that operates within the virtual world. A person who is passive in real life may take the lead and guide others in the online space, or choose a character with an appearance, role, and personality completely different from their own. Ultimately, people have the potential to form a different aspect of their self and identity by experiencing something distinct from reality within this new social space known as the game. Since this identity is formed under conditions and relationships different from those in the real world, it is difficult to view it as always completely identical to one’s real-world identity.
Currently existing virtual worlds are, by their very nature, environments where users are aware that they are artificially created spaces. While users access environments created through computer graphics, head-mounted displays, and various input and output devices, they generally retain their memories and awareness of their real-world selves. However, the situation could change if technology advanced to the point where, as depicted in the movies ‘The Matrix’ or ‘Total Recall’, users could enter a virtual world while their memories and awareness of the real world were completely blocked. If a person were unaware that another world even existed, the world they were experiencing would effectively become their only reality, and the likelihood of identities formed in different worlds directly conflicting would diminish. However, today’s virtual reality users enter virtual spaces while retaining their memories and identities from the real world. Consequently, a discrepancy may arise between the “self” in the real world and the “self” expressed in the virtual world, and in some cases, users may experience psychological conflict or confusion between these two roles and experiences. In the past, the term “reset syndrome” was commonly used to describe the phenomenon of becoming overly immersed in the virtual worlds of games or the internet to the point of blurring the boundaries between reality and the virtual. This term implied that, just as one can press the reset button to restart a computer when it malfunctions, one might believe that events in real life could also be undone. However, “reset syndrome” is not considered an official medical diagnosis recognized internationally today. Currently, the World Health Organization’s (WHO) International Classification of Diseases, 11th Revision (ICD-11), defines “gaming disorder” as a condition in which a person’s ability to control gaming is impaired, gaming takes precedence over other daily activities, and the individual continues or escalates gaming despite negative consequences, resulting in significant functional impairment in important areas of life such as personal, family, social, educational, and occupational functioning. At the same time, the World Health Organization makes it clear that not everyone who plays games develops this disorder; in fact, it is only a small portion of gamers who actually experience problems. Therefore, we should not oversimplify the relationship between the virtual and real worlds by directly linking gaming itself to confusion between reality and the virtual world or to criminal behavior.
Of course, moving between the real and virtual worlds does not necessarily lead to identity confusion for everyone. If a person can distinguish between reality and the virtual world and understand the roles they play in each space, the act of behaving differently in the virtual world than in reality cannot be viewed as a problem in and of itself. Rather, the virtual space can serve as a place to try out roles that are difficult to experience in reality, form relationships with others, and express oneself in new ways. However, for adolescents whose identities are still developing, or for people who are overly immersed in the virtual world to the point that their real-life academics, careers, family relationships, and social lives are affected, managing the relationship between their real-life selves and their virtual selves may be even more important. Even for adults, if activities in the virtual world grow to the point of overwhelming daily life, the possibility of experiencing conflict between the roles they assume in reality and those formed in the virtual space cannot be completely ruled out. Ultimately, in today’s world—where technology has not yet advanced to the point where it is difficult to distinguish reality from the virtual, as depicted in movies like ‘Total Recall’ or ‘The Matrix’—it is important to recognize the virtual world as a separate space based on one’s identity formed in the real world and to have the ability to self-regulate the relationship between the two worlds. As technology advances, the types and forms of virtual spaces in which humans can participate are likely to become even more diverse. Therefore, rather than unconditionally distrusting or rejecting the virtual world, it is important to understand the relationship between our real-world selves and our virtual selves, and to recognize that responsibility for our actions and choices remains constant regardless of which space we inhabit.