In this blog post, starting with the problem of free-riding, I’ll explore whether there truly is a “reason to live righteously” that applies to everyone and every situation.
What does it mean to live the right way? Some might say that living morally is what it means to live the right way, while others might argue that living in accordance with the law is the right way to live. For the purposes of this discussion, let’s consider that it encompasses both of these meanings. Generally, people believe we should act morally and abide by the law. But do we really have a compelling reason to live the right way? Before addressing this question, let’s first examine the concept of “free-riding.”
Have you ever heard the term “free-riding”? Some people might think of free-riding in the context of public transportation, while others might think of it in the context of group projects. Here, I’d like to discuss the latter. Typically, when working in groups, a situation naturally arises where some people take on a lot of work, while others do relatively little. If the disparity in participation levels grows even wider, people may eventually emerge who do almost nothing yet still share in the benefits of the outcome—in other words, “free-riders.” So, what methods are available to prevent this kind of free-riding?
To consider this, we first need to examine why people engage in free-riding. For the purposes of this discussion, let’s define free-riding as a situation where someone contributes significantly less than others yet reaps similar benefits from the collective outcome. Generally, a free-rider may act with the intention of reaping the benefits—such as grades or achievements—while doing almost nothing themselves. So, what would happen if we prevented that person from gaining such benefits? For example, let’s assume we exclude the name of someone who played virtually no role from the list of submitters for a group assignment. In that case, since the free-rider would not be able to share in the good grade, it would be difficult for anyone to choose to free-ride without hesitation. However, this method alone cannot always prevent free-riding. For example, let’s imagine that group members are more interested in improving their own abilities than in the group’s collective grade. If the activity involves writing a research proposal, we assume that group members are solely interested in developing their ability to write research proposals. In such cases, they may not pay much attention to whether others are free-riding; in fact, they might even welcome a situation where others aren’t doing their share. This is because they may believe that taking on the tasks others would have handled is more beneficial for improving their own skills. If the situation develops this way, it becomes very difficult to prevent free-riding through external factors alone, such as scores or penalties. This is because, for some people, others’ free-riding might actually work to their advantage. In that case, group presentations could be considered as another way to prevent this. If all group members are required to participate directly in the presentation, at least everyone will take on the role of presenting, which can prevent complete free-riding to some extent. However, this approach still cannot eliminate the disparities in how much each member contributed to the overall activity. If one person does 1 unit of work out of the total and another does 99 units, then even if everyone participates in the presentation, the situation can still be viewed as effectively close to free-riding.
So, is it really possible to completely prevent free-riding through external factors alone? I think it would likely be difficult to do so. That leaves us with the method of controlling one’s own behavior by personally deciding, “I must not free-ride.” This raises another question: Is there an absolute reason why we shouldn’t free-ride?
There are various possible answers to this. One might say we shouldn’t free-ride because it harms others; another might say it’s immoral; and yet another might explain that it’s simply not the right thing to do. However, it’s hard to guarantee that these reasons apply to everyone. This is because some people might think, “I don’t care if I’m immoral—I’m going to free-ride,” while others might think, “It’s okay if I benefit, even if it causes some harm to others.”
Is there truly a reason why free-riding should be avoided that applies to everyone, without exception, in any situation? I believe it is very difficult to find such a reason. There are currently over 8 billion people living in the world, and each person has different values, ways of life, priorities, and reasons for their actions. Finding a single reason that applies equally to all these diverse individuals at all times is, in fact, extremely difficult.
Now, let’s broaden the issue of free-riding and consider it more generally as the problem of “wrong behavior.” In that case, is there a reason why we should act correctly that applies to every single person in the world, regardless of the situation? Even someone who usually behaves correctly may choose to act incorrectly in a specific situation. A very slight difference in circumstances can completely change a person’s judgment. For example, let’s suppose a person who normally leads a very moral life is faced with a situation where their child or parent is held hostage, and they are demanded to act unjustly or immorally. Of course, even in such extreme situations, there may be people who uphold their moral principles to the very end. However, many people are likely to choose actions they would not normally take in order to save their family. Since this discussion seems to have veered into an overly extreme scenario, let’s return to a more everyday issue and consider it.
I believe there are plenty of reasons to live righteously in everyday situations. For example, let’s suppose you’re walking down the street with no urgent business when you see an elderly woman collapsed on the sidewalk. How should you act in such a situation? Most people would check on the woman’s condition and try to provide necessary assistance or call for help. This is because we’ve been taught that helping someone in distress is the right thing to do, and we’ve naturally internalized these norms through our social interactions. Furthermore, if we deliberately turned a blind eye and walked past someone we could have helped, we might later feel uneasy when reflecting on our actions. Ultimately, various factors—such as education, social norms, conscience, and emotions—can lead us to choose the right course of action.
However, let’s return to the original question. Is there always a reason to live righteously? Would everyone in the situation described above necessarily help the elderly woman who has collapsed? Some people might walk by, assuming someone else will help her, while others might not feel any particular unease about their actions. Furthermore, can we say that the same reasons always apply in the countless complex situations we encounter in real life, rather than in relatively simple scenarios like this one? For example, let’s suppose a child is rushing to an internet café to participate in a gaming event they consider very important. Can we be certain that, upon discovering an elderly woman collapsed on the street, the child will necessarily abandon their goal to help her? Of course, they might help, but we cannot assume that every child would necessarily act that way. This is because, while helping others may be the most important thing to some people, others might consider their own goals or desires more important at that very moment. For this reason, I believe it is difficult to find a “reason to live righteously” that applies without exception to everyone living in the real world, regardless of the situation. Therefore, I have come to the following conclusion:
“There is no single reason to live righteously that applies without exception to everyone and every situation.”
So far, starting with the free-rider problem, I’ve reflected on the reasons for living righteously. There are various ways to prevent free-riding, such as holding presentations in which everyone must participate or limiting the points or benefits a free-rider can earn. These methods can be somewhat effective in general situations.
However, if the situation changes—such as when group members prioritize improving their own abilities over earning points—existing methods may not function properly. Ultimately, there are limits to applying a single method equally to everyone and every situation. Even if we expand the free-rider problem to the broader question of “why we should live rightly,” we arrive at a similar conclusion. While there are various possible explanations—such as the need to avoid harming others, the need to act morally, or the need to follow one’s conscience—it is difficult to assert that any single reason necessarily satisfies every person and every situation in the world. Therefore, I have concluded that there is no single universal and absolute reason that applies to everyone and every situation without exception.
So, for what reason should we live righteously? We need to reflect on the reasons each of us holds. Even if a reason is very important to us personally, we can ask ourselves whether it would carry the same persuasive power if applied directly to someone else. Can the reason I believe compels me to live righteously truly serve as the same reason for others to live righteously as well? Just because it is difficult to find a single, absolute reason that applies to everyone does not mean that the effort to live righteously loses its meaning. On the contrary, the process of reflecting on the values and standards of life that are important to you, and choosing your actions based on those reasons, may be even more important. Rather than searching for a single “correct answer” that applies equally to everyone, I hope you will become someone who lives a righteous life based on your own reasons, while constantly reflecting on why you want to live righteously.