In this blog post, we’ll start with the common saying “a house of cards”—which suggests that houses built on sand easily collapse—and explore three approaches to stabilizing soft soil, along with the conditions under which each method is effective.
- Introduction
- Not all sand is weak soil
- Removing and Replacing Weak Soil
- Reducing Voids Between Soil Particles
- First, apply weight; then, create a path for water to drain
- Compaction Using Impact and Sand Columns
- Altering Soil Properties by Adding Materials
- The fate of a house of cards is not determined by sand alone
Introduction
There is a saying: “a house of cards.” It means that if the foundation is weak—like a tower built on sand—it will not last long. It is a perfectly apt metaphor for emphasizing the importance of a foundation. But can we apply this saying directly to construction sites? Does a building erected on sand inevitably collapse, and is it truly impossible to build a sturdy structure on weak ground?
Not at all! Civil engineering does not rule out the possibility of construction simply because the ground is weak. Instead, it investigates the properties of the soil and addresses any deficiencies to transform it into a state capable of supporting a structure. The technology that makes this possible is known as “soft ground improvement.” However, not every type of soil can be stabilized using the same method. First, we must understand why the ground is weak in the first place.
Not all sand is weak soil
The subgrade is the ground that supports buildings and roads. Problems arise if this ground cannot sufficiently bear the weight of the structure or if it settles excessively under that weight. Soil that lacks the strength to safely support a planned structure or that undergoes significant deformation is referred to as soft ground. Therefore, the suitability of the subgrade depends not only on the type of soil but also on what is built on top of it and how heavy that structure is.
One cannot assume that ground is weak simply because it is sand. Ground composed of sand grains tightly interlocked can support a building under appropriate conditions. On the other hand, loosely packed sand may settle when subjected to a load, as the arrangement of the grains changes. In particular, loose sandy soil saturated with water can undergo “liquefaction”—a phenomenon in which the soil loses its strength during a strong earthquake and behaves like a liquid. What matters most is not the name “sand” itself, but how densely the grains are packed, where the groundwater is located, and what forces the soil is subjected to.
Water-saturated soft clay presents yet another problem. Clay particles are much smaller than those of sand and do not allow water to pass through easily; therefore, even after being loaded, water may continue to drain out over a long period, causing the ground to settle. Even if the surface appears to be similarly flat, what happens underground can be quite different. Soil improvement begins with understanding these differences.
While there are various methods for improving soil, they can be broadly categorized into three approaches to understand the underlying principles. These involve replacing weak soil, reducing the voids between soil particles, or adding materials to alter the soil’s properties. This classification is intended to help understand the representative operating principles rather than an exhaustive list of all construction methods.
Removing and Replacing Weak Soil
The first method involves removing the problematic soil and filling the space with suitable material. A typical example is the “excavation and replacement method,” in which materials that meet design specifications—such as sand or gravel—are placed in the excavated area and thoroughly compacted to form a new subgrade. Rather than leaving the weak section in place and relying on it to bear the load, this method involves replacing that section entirely.
This method can be considered at sites where the soft layer is relatively shallow and easy to excavate. Although the principle is intuitive and the results are relatively easy to verify, this method is not always fast or cost-effective. If the soft layer is deep, the volume of soil to be excavated increases, and additional work may be required to support the excavated space to prevent collapse or to manage groundwater. Actual cost-effectiveness can only be determined by factoring in the cost of bringing in new material as well as the cost of transporting and disposing of the excavated soil.
In soil replacement methods, the key is not simply the fact that “good soil was added.” It is essential to verify whether the replacement extends to the required depth, whether the fill material has been sufficiently compacted, and whether any weak layers remain beneath it. The ground is not considered safe simply because the surface has become firm.
Reducing Voids Between Soil Particles
The second approach involves improving soil performance by reducing the voids between soil particles. Soil is not simply a mass packed tightly with particles. There are voids between the particles, which contain air or water. The primary processes for reducing these voids are “compaction” and “consolidation.” Although the results of these two processes may appear similar, their underlying principles and the time required differ.
Compaction is the process of arranging soil particles more densely using mechanical force; in typical soil compaction, it is primarily the air within the voids that is reduced. Consolidation is the process by which water-saturated soil shrinks in volume as water drains out when the soil is subjected to a load. In particular, compaction can take a long time in clay, which does not drain water easily. Therefore, one should not understand both compaction and consolidation as simply “processes where the soil hardens immediately upon being pressed.”
First, apply weight; then, create a path for water to drain
The “pre-loading method” is a technique in which a load is applied to the ground in advance of construction to induce settlement. For example, if soil is piled up on soft clay ground to apply weight, the water between the soil particles gradually drains away, and the ground undergoes consolidation. This effectively induces a significant portion of the settlement that would otherwise occur after the building is completed. However, if the soil is piled too high too quickly, the ground may not be able to support it; therefore, the load is sometimes increased in stages while monitoring the ground conditions.
The illustration of preloading in the manuscript demonstrates this principle. There is a pile of soil applying weight to a soft clay layer, and beneath it lies a layer of sand that allows water to flow laterally. Depending on the drainage conditions, the water within the clay layer moves either to the sand layer above or to a well-drained stratum below. The key lies not merely in placing a heavy object on top, but in allowing water to drain out of the soil under load.
If it takes too long for the water to drain, the drainage path can be shortened. The “vertical drainage method” involves installing vertical drainage channels within the ground. Methods include “sand drains”—drainage columns made of sand—or plate-shaped drainage materials with a water-conducting core wrapped in a filter. Instead of traveling a long distance to the ground surface, water within the clay flows into nearby drainage materials and is discharged. The second figure in the manuscript shows sand columns erected between clay layers, with arrows pointing toward them, illustrating this shortened drainage path.
This is also the reason for combining preloading with vertical drainage. While preloading provides the load necessary to induce consolidation, vertical drainage helps the consolidation process proceed more rapidly. Installation of the drainage material does not mean the improvement is immediately complete. It is necessary to measure the amount of ground settlement and changes in soil water pressure to verify that the improvement has progressed sufficiently.
Compaction Using Impact and Sand Columns
In loose sand or certain filled soils, mechanical impact can be used to rearrange the particles. A method known as “dynamic compaction” or “dynamic consolidation” involves repeatedly dropping a heavy weight from a fixed height to compact the soil. Vibrocompaction, which involves inserting a vibrating device into the ground, is similar in that it rearranges particles, but the method of force transmission differs. Which method is effective depends on the soil’s particle composition and drainage conditions, among other factors.
The “sand compaction pile method” involves filling the ground with sand and compacting it to form a dense sand column. In loose sandy soil, the process of forming the column displaces and compacts the surrounding soil as well. In soft clay soil, the sand column plays a crucial role in sharing the load with the surrounding clay and aiding drainage. Even though both involve sand columns, this method differs from a sand drain—which is primarily designed for drainage—in terms of design objectives and construction methods.
These methods cannot all be lumped together as “time-consuming and noisy.” For pre-loading, the time required to allow for consolidation is critical, while for dynamic compaction, the noise and vibration generated by the impact are major constraints. When selecting a method, one must consider not only the improvement effects but also the impact on surrounding buildings, the work area, and the construction schedule.
Altering Soil Properties by Adding Materials
The third approach involves adding materials to the soil to increase its strength or make it less permeable to water. This includes methods such as injecting grout into the ground and mixing solidifying agents directly into the soil. While both methods involve adding materials, their mechanisms of action must be distinguished.
Grout injection is a method that involves infiltrating grout—such as water glass (sodium silicate)—into the voids in the soil and then allowing it to harden, thereby increasing the strength of the ground or reducing water flow. Cement-based grouts, made by mixing cement and water, are also used; however, the range of penetration varies depending on the size of the soil’s voids and the particle size of the grout. Therefore, one should not assume that simply adding any material will result in uniform hardening throughout the entire soil mass.
The “mixing treatment method,” which involves mechanically mixing cement- or lime-based solidifying agents with the soil, differs from this. It involves mixing the soil within the ground with solidification agents to create a reinforced material that is highly strong and resistant to compaction. The U.S. Federal Highway Administration’s 2013 Design Guidelines for Deep Mixing also explain that treatment results vary depending on the properties of the original soil, the type of solidification agent, the mixing condition, and the curing time. Just as important as the name of the material is how it is mixed and how thoroughly it is cured.
The grouting method can be useful in areas where high-impact construction techniques are difficult to apply or where workspace is limited. However, the construction period is not always short, nor is it entirely free of noise or vibration. There are impacts from drilling and equipment operation, and time is required for the grout to set. Since the long-term performance of the material and its impact on groundwater must also be verified, cost and environmental impact must be assessed based on the material and site conditions.
The fate of a house of cards is not determined by sand alone
So, is it possible to build a sturdy structure on sand? Of course it is. However, this answer comes with conditions. The degree of sand compaction, groundwater conditions, the depth of weak strata, and the weight of the building must be investigated, and the foundation and ground improvement methods must be designed accordingly. After construction is complete, it is also necessary to verify that the targeted performance has been achieved.
Building on sand is not always uneconomical. A sufficiently dense sandy subgrade may not require large-scale improvement, whereas a thick layer of soft clay may necessitate a long construction period or significant costs. Economic feasibility should not be judged by whether the ground is “sand or not,” but rather by the work and costs required to ensure the necessary safety and usability.
The expression “a house of cards” remains valid today. This is because if the foundation is neglected, whatever is built on top of it will be unstable. However, civil engineering adds one more sentence to that metaphor: just because the ground is weak at the outset does not mean it must remain weak forever. What makes a house built on sand dangerous is not the fact that it is sand, but rather a failure to understand the nature of the ground—or, even if understood, a failure to take the necessary measures.