In this blog post, we will examine why altruistic behavior—in which people sacrifice some of their own interests to benefit others—can persist from the perspective of repeated interactions and reciprocity. We will also use the examples of sharing snacks and regular customers to specifically explain the significance and limitations of the repeated reciprocity hypothesis.
Altruistic behavior generally refers to making a choice that benefits another person while incurring some degree of cost or loss compared to what one would have faced had they made a different choice. From an evolutionary perspective, this behavior raises a question: if a selfish person and an altruistic person repeatedly make their respective choices in the same situation, and the altruistic person receives no reward whatsoever, the altruistic person may suffer cumulative losses. Under such conditions, altruistic behavior might be expected to be disadvantageous for survival and reproduction, and one might predict that altruistic tendencies would diminish over successive generations. However, in actual human society, it is not difficult to find instances of people helping others or sharing their possessions even while incurring some personal loss. So how is it possible for altruistic people to exist? One perspective that explains this question is the “repeated reciprocity hypothesis,” which focuses on repeated interactions and reciprocity.
The core of the repeated reciprocity hypothesis is that, in recurring situations, previous choices influence current choices, and current choices can in turn influence future choices. To understand this, let’s consider a scenario involving sharing cookies. Most people have had the experience of eating snacks and have also encountered a friend who has a different kind of snack than they do. In such a situation, if you can get a small taste of your friend’s snack, you might derive greater satisfaction than if you were to eat only your own snack. So, from your own perspective, is sharing your snack with a friend always the obvious choice? You could also choose to act selfishly by taking a bite of your friend’s snack without giving any of your own in return. Even if you make the altruistic choice to share your snacks, there’s no guarantee that your friend will share theirs in return. Yet, in reality, many people choose to share their snacks with friends.
Let’s examine this situation in a bit more detail. Suppose the satisfaction gained from eating only your own snacks is 5, the cost incurred by sharing your snacks with a friend is -2, and the additional satisfaction gained from receiving a different kind of snack from your friend is +4. The assumption here is that if you can taste various kinds of snacks, you’ll experience greater satisfaction than if you ate only your own. Under these conditions, if you share your snacks with your friend and also receive some from them, your satisfaction is 7. On the other hand, if you only share your snacks and do not receive any from your friend, your satisfaction is 3. Applying these assumptions to each possible choice yields the following results.
You: Share / Friend: Shares / Satisfaction: (7, 7)
You: Share / Friend: Does not share / Satisfaction: (3, 9)
Me: Does not share / Friend: Shares / Satisfaction: (9, 3)
Me: Does not share / Friend: Does not share / Satisfaction: (5, 5)
Based solely on these results, regardless of the friend’s choice, one can achieve higher satisfaction by not sharing one’s own snacks. When the friend shares their cookies and I share mine as well, my satisfaction is 7, but if I don’t share, it rises to 9. Even when the friend doesn’t share their cookies, if I share mine, my satisfaction is 3, but if I don’t share, it rises to 5. Therefore, when considering a single choice, not sharing my cookies appears to be the more advantageous option for me.
However, the key point here is that the other person is not a complete stranger but a “friend.” Generally, a friend is not someone you meet once or twice and never see again. It is highly likely that you will meet the same friend again, and situations where you must decide whether to share not only snacks but also various other items or offer help to one another may recur. When interactions like this are repeated, it becomes difficult to judge behavior based solely on the benefit gained from a single choice. If a friend did not share their snacks last time, you might be inclined not to share yours this time. Conversely, if a friend shared their snacks last time, you might be more inclined to share yours this time. In other words, in a situation where you adjust your behavior based on the other person’s past actions, a selfish choice in the present can lead to uncooperative behavior from the other person in the future. This is because even if you gain greater satisfaction by not sharing your snacks this time, your friend might also choose not to share next time. Conversely, if you choose to share your snacks, there is a possibility that the other person will respond with cooperative behavior in the future. If this relationship continues over the long term, a choice that involves accepting a small immediate loss to benefit the other person can ultimately benefit you as well. It is precisely this “repeatability” and “reciprocity”—responding to the other party’s past behavior—that create the conditions for cooperative or altruistic behavior to be sustained.
So, does repeated reciprocity only occur in situations like sharing cookies? It’s not hard to find similar patterns in everyday life. For example, when a regular customer asks a restaurant owner for a price adjustment or additional service, the owner may agree to the request. A similar situation can arise in the relationship between a customer who regularly orders boxed lunches and the vendor. If the transaction between the vendor and the customer were a one-time event, the vendor might have little reason to lower the price at the expense of their own profit. However, the situation changes if there is a high likelihood of repeated transactions in the future, as with a regular customer or a customer who places recurring orders. This is because even if the seller concedes some profit in this particular transaction, as long as the customer continues to return, more transactions can be sustained in the long run. Strictly speaking, it is difficult to define all such behavior as altruistic in the purest sense; however, in that it pursues long-term mutual benefit by sacrificing a portion of short-term profit, it serves as an example illustrating how repetition and reciprocity form cooperative behavior.
Of course, repetitive reciprocity alone cannot explain all human altruistic behavior. There are cases where people help others with whom they are highly unlikely to meet again, such as donating a substantial amount of money to a stranger encountered on the street. Furthermore, there are instances that are difficult to explain solely through simple repetitive reciprocity, such as the behavior of parents who consistently provide time and resources to their children even without receiving any specific reward in return. To explain altruistic behavior, it is necessary to consider various evolutionary and social perspectives—such as kin selection and explanations related to reputation or social signals—in addition to repetitive reciprocity. For example, altruistic behavior observed in genetically close relationships, such as between parents and children, can be explained from the perspective of kin selection, while behavior that signals one’s cooperativeness or ability to hold resources to others is sometimes discussed in terms of signaling, which can entail costs depending on the situation. Therefore, rather than attempting to explain all human altruism with a single hypothesis, it is more appropriate to view it as a phenomenon where different explanations may apply depending on the relationship and situation in which the behavior occurs.
Even considering these limitations, explanations based on repetition and reciprocity provide an important perspective for understanding why humans cooperate with others and sometimes sacrifice their own short-term interests. In situations where interactions are repeated and the other party responds to previous behavior, an action that appears to be a loss when viewed in isolation can yield greater long-term benefits. This is because cooperating with a partner with whom one is likely to meet again increases the likelihood that the partner will respond in kind, and as this relationship continues, mutually beneficial behavior can be sustained. Therefore, rather than being a theory that solely explains all altruistic behavior in humans, the repeated reciprocity hypothesis can be regarded as an important explanatory framework for understanding how cooperation and altruistic behavior can be maintained and developed within repeated human relationships.