What are black holes, and how are they formed and observed?

In this blog post, we’ll explore the basic principles and formation processes of black holes—from which even light struggles to escape—as well as the observational methods used to confirm their existence despite the fact that we cannot see them directly, and the journey from theoretical concepts to their acceptance as actual celestial objects.

 

Even people who haven’t studied physics professionally have likely heard the term “black hole” at least once. Black holes, along with wormholes and white holes, frequently appear in science fiction movies and novels featuring time travel or space as their subject matter. However, from a scientific perspective, black holes cannot be viewed in the same light as wormholes or white holes. Wormholes are hypothetical structures whose possibility is discussed in certain solutions to the general theory of relativity, and while white holes are also theoretically proposed concepts, no observational evidence proving their actual existence has been confirmed to date. In contrast, the existence of black holes has been confirmed not only by theoretical predictions but also through various astronomical observations. Not only have X-rays and radio waves emitted by matter around black holes, as well as the motion of nearby celestial bodies, been detected, but gravitational waves generated during black hole mergers have also been observed; furthermore, the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) has successfully produced images of the region surrounding a black hole. Therefore, today, black holes are not merely scientific imaginings or hypotheses, but celestial objects that modern astronomy and physics actually observe and study.
A black hole refers to a celestial object or region of spacetime where gravity is so extreme that not even light can escape from inside its event horizon. To intuitively understand the principle of black holes, one can consider the concepts of gravity and escape velocity. According to Newton’s law of universal gravitation, a force of mutual attraction acts between two objects with mass; this force is proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them. Therefore, as mass increases and the distance between objects decreases, the gravitational pull becomes stronger. In everyday life, the gravitational force between surrounding objects is so small that it is difficult for a person to feel it directly; however, the gravitational force generated by a celestial body with a very large mass, such as Earth, can be clearly felt. It is this gravitational force that causes objects on the Earth’s surface to be pulled toward the center of the Earth. The minimum speed required to escape Earth’s gravity and avoid falling back to the surface is called the escape velocity. If a celestial body has a very large mass and that mass is extremely compressed into a small space, the speed required to escape increases accordingly. Using the classical concept of escape velocity as an analogy, we can understand that in regions where this speed exceeds the speed of light, not even light can escape. However, the exact physical properties of black holes cannot be explained by Newtonian mechanics alone but must be explained through Einstein’s general theory of relativity. In the general theory of relativity, mass and energy cause spacetime to curve, and light also travels along this curved spacetime. Light that crosses a black hole’s event horizon cannot return to the outside.
For a person to see an object with their eyes, light emitted or reflected by that object must reach the eye. However, since light inside the event horizon of a black hole cannot escape to the outside, black holes cannot be observed directly like ordinary celestial objects. So how do scientists know that black holes exist? Instead of observing light emitted by the black hole itself, astronomers observe the effects that black holes have on surrounding matter and spacetime. One of the primary methods is X-ray observation. If a black hole forms a binary system with a star, material from the companion star can be pulled toward the black hole, forming an extremely hot accretion disk around it. Rather than falling directly into the black hole, this material spins rapidly, heating up to high temperatures and emitting electromagnetic radiation across various wavelengths, including intense X-rays.
By analyzing this radiation and the motion of the companion star, astronomers can determine the existence and mass of the invisible black hole. X-rays are high-energy electromagnetic waves that are invisible to the human eye. Furthermore, since most X-rays from space are absorbed by Earth’s atmosphere, space-based observation equipment, such as the Chandra X-ray Observatory, is essential for astronomical X-ray observations. Contrary to the original text’s description that X-rays are observed using radio telescopes, X-rays are actually observed with X-ray detection equipment, while radio telescopes are used to observe radio waves emitted from the vicinity of black holes. Today, black holes are studied through various methods, including not only X-ray observations but also the orbital motion of surrounding stars, gravitational lensing effects, radio observations, and gravitational wave observations. In particular, in 2015, LIGO made the first direct detection of gravitational waves generated by the merger of two black holes, adding a new observational method to black hole research. Furthermore, the EHT connects radio telescopes in various regions around the world to form a virtual telescope the size of Earth, and in 2019, it produced the first image of the bright ring and dark shadow surrounding the supermassive black hole M87′ at the center of the galaxy M87. In 2022, it also revealed the appearance of Sagittarius A’ (Sagittarius A’), the supermassive black hole at the center of our Milky Way.
The process by which black holes form cannot be explained by a single mechanism. Prot black holes are hypothetical black holes proposed to have formed when matter in specific regions was strongly compressed in the early universe—an era immediately following the Big Bang when the universe was extremely hot and dense. Theoretical studies suggest that, under the conditions of the early universe, black holes with a wide range of masses may have formed in ways different from those observed today. However, since no conclusive observational evidence has yet been found to confirm the actual existence of primordial black holes, we cannot definitively conclude that they were produced in vast numbers. Since the current universe does not possess the same high-density environment as the early universe, it is not believed that primordial black holes are forming anew in this manner. The existence of primordial black holes remains one of the key research topics in cosmology and dark matter studies today.
One of the relatively well-understood processes of black hole formation is linked to the evolution of very massive stars. After a star is born, it spends a long time undergoing nuclear fusion in its core; when its fuel is exhausted, it enters a final stage that varies depending on its initial mass. Stars with masses similar to or smaller than the Sun may expel their outer layers during the final stage of their evolution, leaving behind a central core that becomes a white dwarf. A white dwarf is a high-density object that does not generate new energy through nuclear fusion but resists gravitational collapse due to electron degeneracy pressure. In contrast, when the nuclear fuel in the core of a much more massive star is exhausted, the pressure supporting the structure weakens, causing the central core to collapse rapidly. This process can trigger a supernova explosion, and depending on the mass of the remaining core, a neutron star or a black hole may form. A neutron star is an ultra-dense celestial object in which matter is extremely compressed to a density comparable to that of an atomic nucleus, but it is not the same as a black hole. If the central core is sufficiently massive to prevent gravitational collapse, an event horizon forms, resulting in the creation of a stellar-mass black hole. Therefore, it is inaccurate to define a black hole simply as a “neutron star with a density approaching infinity.” In the classical solutions of general relativity, a singularity appears inside a black hole; however, the actual state of matter and spacetime in that extreme region remains an unsolved problem in physics that requires the combined consideration of general relativity and quantum mechanics. Furthermore, various hypotheses and studies are underway regarding how supermassive black holes—found at the centers of galaxies and ranging from hundreds of thousands to billions of times the mass of the Sun—were initially formed and grew.
The concept of black holes did not suddenly emerge in modern times. In the 18th century, the British natural philosopher John Mitchell, drawing on Newtonian mechanics, proposed the possibility of celestial bodies where gravity was so strong that not even light could escape. Mitchell’s discussion was presented to the Royal Society in 1783 and published in 1784; subsequently, the French mathematician Pierre-Simon Laplace also discussed a similar concept. However, Newtonian mechanics alone at that time could not fully explain the properties of black holes as we understand them today. In the 20th century, with the advent of Einstein’s general theory of relativity and the subsequent development of research on the properties of spacetime in strong gravitational fields based on that theory, the theoretical foundation for black holes was established. Subsequently, as astronomical observation techniques advanced, evidence supporting the existence of black holes—which had previously been discussed only theoretically—began to emerge one by one. Cygnus X-1, located in the constellation Cygnus, is a particularly important celestial object in this process. Cygnus X-1 is a powerful X-ray source discovered through X-ray observations in 1964. Subsequent analysis of the motion of its companion star and the characteristics of its X-ray emission provided strong evidence that the invisible companion was a black hole. Consequently, Cygnus X-1 became one of the first celestial objects widely recognized as a black hole. Today, the existence of black holes is not explained solely by X-ray binary systems such as Cygnus X-1. Various independent observational results—including the motion of stars and gas, gravitational waves generated by black hole mergers, radio observations around supermassive black holes, and the black hole shadow captured by the EHT—strongly support the existence of black holes and the predictions of general relativity. Thus, black holes are celestial objects whose existence has been confirmed through lengthy theoretical debate and advances in observational technology; today, they have become a central subject of research in modern physics and astronomy, playing a crucial role in studying the nature of gravity and spacetime and in understanding the evolution of stars and galaxies.

 

About the author

Cam Tien

I love things that are gentle and cute. I love dogs, cats, and flowers because they make me happy. I also enjoy eating and traveling to discover new things. Besides that, I like to lie back, take in the scenery, and relax to enjoy life.