In this blog post, using the issues of genetic selection and human genetic engineering raised by the movie ‘Gattaca’ (1997) as a starting point, we will examine the scientific, social, and ethical problems that could arise from selecting or editing a person’s genetic traits before birth.
- How does the movie 'Gattaca' portray a society based on genetic selection?
- What are the scientific issues with gene selection and editing?
- Would society become happier if there were more genetically “superior humans”?
- Is it ethically justifiable to select and edit human genes?
- To what extent should scientific progress be allowed to alter human life?
How does the movie ‘Gattaca’ portray a society based on genetic selection?
As can be inferred from the fact that the title ‘Gattaca’ consists solely of the letters representing the nucleotides that make up DNA—adenine (A), thymine (T), guanine (G), and cytosine (C)—the film depicts a facet of a future society where genetics and biotechnology are highly advanced. The film’s protagonist, Vincent, was born through natural childbirth and is classified as genetically disadvantaged. However, after making relentless efforts—such as devoting himself to his studies and athletics and assuming someone else’s identity to conceal his genetic information—he ultimately surpasses those deemed genetically superior and is selected as an astronaut, thereby fulfilling his dream. Anyone who has seen this film—even without specialized background knowledge in genetics—can likely reflect to some extent on what it means to live in a society that evaluates and selects people based on their genetic information. The 1990s, when the film was released, was a time of rapid advancement in human genome research and biotechnology. Since then, with the emergence of the Human Genome Project, preimplantation genetic testing, and gene-editing technologies such as CRISPR-Cas9, the issues raised by the film have ceased to be mere science fiction. However, today we must scientifically distinguish between embryo selection—the process of screening embryos obtained through in vitro fertilization based on specific genetic conditions—and gene editing, which alters the DNA itself. Nevertheless, the issues of selecting human births based on desired genetic traits or editing human genes in a heritable manner raise interconnected scientific, social, and ethical concerns. When considering these issues comprehensively, I believe that—aside from limited medical applications for disease treatment—gene selection and heritable gene editing aimed at enhancing human abilities or characteristics should be carefully restricted.
What are the scientific issues with gene selection and editing?
First, we need to examine genetic screening and gene editing from a scientific perspective. At first glance, one might think that selecting genetically advantageous traits poses no particular problem from a scientific standpoint, and this could serve as a basis for supporting the active selection or modification of human genetic traits. This is because if specific genetic mutations that cause diseases can be avoided, it is possible to reduce the risk of serious genetic disorders. In fact, preimplantation genetic testing is currently used during in vitro fertilization to screen for specific genetic disorders or chromosomal abnormalities. However, identifying genetic risks associated with disease is an entirely different matter from selecting complex traits such as intelligence, physical ability, or appearance to create so-called “superior humans.” Many human traits are not determined by a single gene but result from the complex interplay of numerous genes, the environment, and the developmental process. Critics continue to point out that even technologies aimed at selecting embryos by predicting the risk of multifactorial diseases face significant limitations in clinical application due to the uncertainty of predictions and the complexity of gene-environment interactions. Therefore, the very idea that one can select “superior genes” in every respect to design human capabilities in a desired direction is an excessive oversimplification of current genetics.
Furthermore, even if genetic screening were to take place, it does not mean that the selected individuals would all possess identical genetic sequences. There are vast differences in the human genome from person to person, and it is realistically impossible for the entire genome to become uniform simply by selecting embryos based on a few specific traits. However, it is conceivable that if society as a whole were to prefer and select only specific genetic traits over a long period, pressure could build toward a reduction in the diversity of certain genes and traits. Genetic diversity is also related to susceptibility to disease. In fact, genetic differences play a role in why individuals vary in their susceptibility to infectious diseases, and genetic diversity related to immune responses can be linked to resistance to specific infectious diseases. Therefore, it can be risky to uniformly define a specific trait as “superior” and for society as a whole to repeatedly make genetic selections in the same direction, as it is difficult to fully predict the long-term consequences. While past arguments—such as the idea that “if everyone had the same genes, the entire population would be wiped out by a single disease”—are overly simplistic, the underlying concern that we must carefully examine the long-term consequences of selection that narrows genetic diversity remains valid.
A similar line of concern is portrayed in an extreme form in the Naver Webtoon “No Name.” “No Name” depicts a society composed of genetically selected humans and, through events involving viruses, artificial intelligence, and advanced science and technology, imagines the dangers that could arise when humans attempt to exert excessive control over themselves using science and technology. Of course, this is a work of science fiction that draws on imaginative storytelling rather than scientific predictions or actual research findings. Therefore, we cannot definitively conclude that the situations depicted in the work will actually occur in the future. However, it serves as a noteworthy example in that it prompts us to consider that technological advancements do not always proceed in the direction humans anticipate, and that when problems arise with life-related technologies, it may be difficult to reverse the consequences.
It is also inappropriate to conclude, based solely on current scientific evidence, that humans born through gene editing will directly cause any adverse effects on the ecosystem. Assumptions—such as that gene-edited humans might produce toxic substances and release them into the environment after eating certain plants, or that special ecological problems might arise during the decomposition of their bodies—are not scientifically verified facts but rather hypothetical possibilities. However, the possibility of unexpected biological effects arising from human genetic modification must be considered more realistically. This is because a single gene can influence multiple traits, and the interactions between genes and environmental influences are complex. In particular, gene editing performed on germ cells or at the embryonic stage must be evaluated for a much broader range of risks than treatments targeting somatic cells, as the changes can be passed on to future generations. For these reasons, international organizations—including the World Health Organization—and the scientific community agree that the clinical application of heritable human gene editing requires a high level of safety verification as well as thorough social and ethical deliberation.
Would society become happier if there were more genetically “superior humans”?
Second, let’s examine this from a social perspective. If we accept the assumption that human traits—such as intelligence, physical abilities, and resistance to disease—can be selected according to our preferences, we might expect society’s productivity and research capabilities to increase. This is because we might imagine that new discoveries would emerge in fields where unsolved problems persist or where research has been insufficient, and that society would function more efficiently as the number of people with high cognitive and physical abilities grows. However, this expectation is based on the hidden premise that human capabilities are determined solely by genes. In reality, various factors—such as education, family environment, social conditions, experience, and individual effort—influence human abilities and achievements. Moreover, even if a society were created where everyone possessed similarly high abilities, differences and competition among people would not disappear. Nevertheless, if society were to define specific abilities as the standard for “superior genes” and begin selecting people based on that standard, it is entirely plausible that new forms of comparison and discrimination would emerge.
Humans are social beings who form relationships with others and evaluate their own position and achievements by comparing themselves to those around them. The discussion of reference groups and relative deprivation addressed by Robert K. Merton in ‘Social Theory and Social Structure’ also demonstrates that an individual’s sense of satisfaction is not determined solely by absolute conditions but can be influenced by their relationships with the people or groups against whom they compare themselves. That said, we cannot conclude that a person must be superior to others to be happy. However, in a society that evaluates everyone’s abilities according to uniform standards and compels them to compete to possess superior traits, the benchmarks for comparison are likely to become even higher. While competition is an important element in the games and sports people enjoy today, these activities do not exist solely because of differences in genetic ability. Various factors come into play, such as training, experience, strategy, cooperation, and creativity. Therefore, it is difficult to argue that an increase in genetically superior individuals would render leisure activities like games or sports impossible. Rather, the more significant concern is that when society begins to evaluate human worth based on a limited set of genetic abilities, diversity itself may be treated as of lesser value.
Furthermore, it cannot be assumed that high ability is always used solely for socially desirable purposes. Not all humans have good intentions, and individual abilities—such as intelligence, knowledge, and physical ability—can produce entirely different outcomes depending on the user’s purpose. While Hervey M. Cleckley’s ‘The Mask of Sanity’ is a classic work that clinically describes psychopathic traits, it is inappropriate to use it as evidence to claim that people with psychopathic tendencies are generally highly intelligent. Modern research has not identified a clear positive correlation between psychopathic traits and intelligence; in fact, some studies have even reported a very weak negative correlation. Therefore, the crux of the issue is not that “there are an increasing number of psychopaths with high intelligence.” The key point is that even if any ability—including cognitive ability—is enhanced, it does not automatically lead to an increase in that person’s morality or sense of responsibility. If technologies that intentionally enhance specific human abilities become a reality, the possibility that such abilities could be exploited in negative ways—such as crime, exploitation, or the concentration of power—must also be considered at the societal level.
Is it ethically justifiable to select and edit human genes?
Finally, from an ethical perspective, the issue becomes even more complex. To create humans with desired genetic traits, the safety and efficacy of the technology must be thoroughly verified. In the past, concerns were raised that, since animal experiments alone are insufficient to confirm the results of genetic manipulation related to human birth, experiments would ultimately have to be conducted on a large number of human embryos. Even today, while animal models and cellular research play a crucial role in verifying the efficacy and risks of gene-editing technologies, they cannot fully substitute for the developmental process of human embryos or the effects of heritable gene editing. In particular, since changes made to embryos do not end with the individual born but may be passed on to future generations, a higher level of safety verification is required than for general therapeutic technologies. During the gene-editing process, it is essential to carefully examine changes occurring outside the intended target site, unexpected genetic alterations, and variations in editing outcomes across different cells within the embryo. The international scientific community also emphasizes the principle that the safety and efficacy of heritable human gene editing must be sufficiently demonstrated before it leads to actual births, and that social consensus and a rigorous regulatory framework are necessary.
The use of embryos as research subjects has also long been the subject of ethical debate. As noted in the original text, it is difficult to simply describe the ethical issues surrounding embryos by citing the number of reports or stating that “the majority of people view embryos as fully-fledged life.” There are differing views across the fields of religion, philosophy, law, and bioethics regarding when an embryo’s moral status should be recognized. For this reason, modern bioethics systems, rather than establishing any single philosophical view as an established fact, impose specific restrictions and consent procedures on the creation, use, research, preservation, and disposal of embryos. South Korea’s “Act on Bioethics and Safety” also prohibits the creation of embryos for purposes other than pregnancy and requires consent procedures for the creation, preservation, disposal, and use of embryos for research purposes. Furthermore, current regulations in South Korea prohibit the application of gene therapy to embryos, oocytes, sperm, and fetuses. This demonstrates that genetic modifications to embryos and germ cells are treated not merely as a matter of individual treatment, but as a bioethical issue that could affect future generations and society as a whole.
Even if it becomes technically possible to perform highly precise genetic editing, this does not mean that all ethical issues will be resolved. Effects that were not identified during the research phase may emerge during the growth process or in adulthood, and if those changes are passed on to the next generation, the scope of those affected will widen even further. In particular, if unexpected health problems arise due to artificially altered genetic traits, it is no easy task to determine who should be held responsible for those risks and to what extent. More fundamentally, the question remains: to what extent can parents, medical professionals, or society determine the genetic characteristics of a person yet to be born? Of course, no one can choose which genes they are born with, and parents also make various decisions regarding their children’s educational and living environments before they are born. Therefore, one cannot claim that all reproductive medical technologies are unjust simply because it is impossible to obtain the prior consent of the unborn person. However, if we go beyond medical interventions aimed at preventing disease and proceed to a stage where others select or alter traits such as intelligence, appearance, and physical abilities, much larger ethical issues arise concerning autonomy, human dignity, discrimination, and social inequality. This is why the World Health Organization and UNESCO call for a particularly cautious approach to the editing of heritable human genes.
To what extent should scientific progress be allowed to alter human life?
When examining the issues of human gene selection and gene editing from scientific, social, and ethical perspectives, it becomes clear that while these technologies hold the potential to prevent or treat diseases, they are also accompanied by highly complex risks and ethical concerns. In particular, today it is necessary to distinguish between technologies that edit a patient’s somatic cells to treat disease and heritable gene editing, which alters the genes of embryos or germ cells so that the changes are passed on to future generations. While the former has already begun to be used in the treatment of certain diseases, the latter requires much stricter scientific and ethical standards because it can affect future generations. Furthermore, selecting embryos free of specific genetic disorders to prevent disease cannot be equated with screening embryos to create humans with socially preferred traits, such as intelligence, physical appearance, or athletic ability.
The world in which humans currently live is filled with countless diseases and hardships. However, the solution does not necessarily have to involve selecting humans according to a desired profile or artificially designing the genes of future generations. Finding ways to reduce suffering caused by disease while minimizing new bioethical issues and social discrimination is an important direction that science should pursue. While scientific progress is necessary, this does not mean that everything should be implemented simply because it is technically feasible. We must examine the impact that technology will have on humans and society, and determine the direction of progress while considering safety, human dignity, individual rights, and social equity. Rather than judging which life is superior based on human genetic characteristics and selecting human births according to those criteria, it is preferable to develop safer and more responsible scientific methods that can prevent and treat diseases while respecting human diversity. Ultimately, the role of science is not to create a “perfect human,” but to help existing humans live healthier and more dignified lives.