Can We Really Say That Low-Dose Radiation Is Safe?

In this blog post, we’ll examine the risks of low-dose radiation—which became a subject of controversy following the Fukushima nuclear accident—as well as the LNT model, the radiation adaptation response, and the hormesis theory. We’ll also explore how we should understand the safety of radiation based on current research.

 

The Fukushima Nuclear Accident: Is Low-Dose Radiation Really Safe?

Suddenly, the ground shook violently. A tsunami then swept over the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant. As the massive tsunami caused the successive loss of power and cooling systems, the reactor cores in Units 1 through 3 overheated and the nuclear fuel melted. Hydrogen was generated during this process, leading to a series of hydrogen explosions in the reactor buildings. The release of radioactive materials into the atmosphere and the ocean sent shockwaves around the world. People were reminded of the nightmare of the Chernobyl nuclear accident. The Fukushima Daiichi accident occurred on March 11, 2011.
At the time of the accident, seawater was injected into the reactors to cool them, but this also led to the leakage of water contaminated with radioactive materials into the surrounding environment. As the accident unfolded, residents within a 20-kilometer radius of the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant were evacuated, and the incident was rated Level 7 on the International Nuclear Event Scale (INES). This corresponds to a severe accident, the highest level on the INES scale.
Following the accident, concerns grew not only in Japan but also in South Korea regarding the possibility of radioactive materials spreading through the ocean and the atmosphere. At the time, a wide range of information and rumors regarding radiation spread rapidly via the internet and social media. Arguments that overly emphasized the dangers of radiation clashed with those that, conversely, downplayed them.
One side argued that even low-dose radiation could increase health risks, including cancer, while the other contended that radiation below a certain level is recoverable by the human body and, in some cases, could even activate biological defense mechanisms. Since both sides cited scientific research and theories as evidence, the general public was inevitably confused about which explanation to accept.
So, is low-dose radiation really safe? Based on current scientific knowledge, it is difficult to answer this question simply by saying “safe” or “dangerous.” However, in the field of radiation protection, the LNT model is used as a practical framework for assessing and managing the risks of low-dose radiation, and the hormesis theory—which posits that low-dose radiation is beneficial to the human body—is not adopted as a basis for radiation protection. Furthermore, research accumulated since the Fukushima accident consistently concludes that it is difficult to confirm any adverse health effects in the general public resulting from radiation exposure caused by the accident.

 

What is low-dose radiation?

Low-dose radiation, as the term suggests, refers to cases where the amount of radiation received by the human body is relatively small. In radiation research, exposure of 100 mSv or less is generally classified as low-dose. However, the term “low-dose” is not an absolute threshold but can be applied differently depending on the research objective, the type of radiation, and the method of exposure. This is because the effects of radiation are not determined solely by the total dose but are also influenced by factors such as the type of radiation, exposure duration, dose rate, the area of the body exposed, and age.
People are not only exposed to radiation in artificial environments such as nuclear power plants or medical devices. They are also exposed to radiation in the natural environment, including soil, rocks, cosmic rays, food, and water. The global average annual exposure to natural radiation is known to be approximately 2.4 mSv, though there are significant regional variations. People may also be exposed to radiation from medical X-rays or CT scans. In particular, the radiation dose from a CT scan varies depending on the area being imaged, the imaging method, and the equipment used; therefore, it is difficult to make a blanket comparison such as “equivalent to X number of CT scans.”
The problem lies in the fact that it is not easy to accurately measure the effects of low-dose radiation on the human body. At very low levels of radiation-induced cancer risk, it is difficult to distinguish between cancer cases caused by natural factors or other environmental factors. Therefore, when studying the risks of low-dose radiation, large-scale epidemiological studies, biological research, and statistical models are used in combination.

 

What is the LNT model, which assumes that radiation has no threshold?

The LNT model stands for “Linear No-Threshold model.” This model does not assume that the risk of cancer from radiation suddenly disappears below a certain threshold; rather, it posits that the risk increases as the radiation dose increases. Therefore, it does not conclude that the additional risk is completely zero even at very low levels of radiation.
A key point of the LNT model is that it does not assume that “an absolute safe threshold for radiation has been scientifically established.” In radiation protection, given the difficulty of directly measuring risk in the low-dose range, the risk in that range is estimated based on data from the observable medium- and high-dose ranges, as well as biological evidence. The International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) continues to utilize the LNT assumption in the practical risk management of radiation protection. However, the LNT model should not be understood as a natural law that accurately predicts the actual risk of cancer in the low-dose range, and there is considerable uncertainty regarding the magnitude of risk at low doses.
According to the LNT model, as the amount of radiation exposure increases, the corresponding probabilistic risk also increases. It is important to note that the biological effects of radiation are influenced by various factors—not just the radiation dose—including whether the exposure occurred in a single event or over a long period, the type and dose rate of the radiation, and the extent of exposure to specific organs. Therefore, when assessing actual effects on the human body, radiation dose alone cannot fully account for all situations.
Past studies have included epidemiological research aimed at estimating the relationship between diagnostic X-ray examinations and cancer incidence. These studies suggested a potential link between medical radiation exposure and cancer risk. Even today, large-scale epidemiological studies continue to investigate the relationship between low-dose, low-dose-rate radiation exposure and cancer risk. A large-scale study published by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) on radiation workers at nuclear power plants and industrial sites also reported an association between long-term low-dose radiation exposure and the risk of death from solid cancers. However, it is important to note that the risk associated with individual low-level exposures is very small, making it difficult to measure its exact magnitude.
In addition, research on the effects of low-dose radiation on conditions such as cataracts and cardiovascular diseases has been ongoing for a long time. The effects of radiation on the human body are not limited to cancer; various biological changes can occur depending on the dose, dose rate, and site of exposure. However, there remains research uncertainty regarding the specific health effects associated with low doses, and radiation risks cannot be applied uniformly to all diseases. International organizations establish radiation protection standards while taking these uncertainties into account.

 

Can living organisms adapt to radiation?

Radiation adaptation refers to the phenomenon in which organisms exhibit relatively strong resistance to higher levels of radiation after having been initially exposed to low levels of radiation. Past experiments have reported that cells or laboratory animals pre-exposed to low-dose radiation can exhibit specific defensive responses to subsequent radiation exposure.
In these studies, the fact that various biological defense mechanisms—such as DNA damage repair or the elimination of damaged cells—can be activated when cells are exposed to radiation served as important evidence. In fact, biological cells possess multiple mechanisms for detecting and repairing DNA damage, and the response to radiation cannot be explained by a single process of “damage” alone.
Some experiments have reported that laboratory animals first exposed to low-dose radiation exhibited higher survival rates than control groups when subsequently exposed to high-dose radiation. These results were interpreted as evidence suggesting that low-dose radiation may stimulate biological defense mechanisms.
However, this raises an important question: Can the adaptive responses observed in laboratory animals or cells be directly applied to humans? An organism’s response to radiation can vary depending on species, tissue, genetic background, dose, and dose rate. Therefore, the mere observation of an adaptive response in a specific experiment does not allow us to conclude that humans have adapted to natural radiation or trace amounts of external radiation, thereby eliminating health risks.
Even within the current radiation protection framework, a distinction is made between the fact that adaptive responses are a subject of research and the idea that they can be applied to actual radiation protection standards. While the possibility that biological phenomena such as adaptive responses or hormesis may be observed under certain conditions is being studied, radiation exposure is not considered beneficial to health based on these phenomena.

 

Could moderate radiation exposure actually be beneficial to the body?

The theory of radiation hormesis applies the concept of hormesis—which posits that substances or stimuli that are harmful in large doses can actually have beneficial effects on organisms in very small amounts—to radiation. In medicine and biology, various phenomena have been studied in which mild stimuli can activate an organism’s defense mechanisms, and radiation hormesis was proposed from this perspective.
Studies advocating radiation hormesis have reported that low-dose radiation can stimulate cellular defense mechanisms and immune responses, thereby exerting a positive influence on living organisms. In the past, there were also studies that examined various indicators—such as cancer incidence, reproductive capacity, resistance to infection, aging, and lifespan—in laboratory animals. Based on these results, some researchers have argued that low-dose radiation is not merely harmful and may even be beneficial to organisms at certain levels.
However, the claim that radiation hormesis applies to humans is not a conclusion generally accepted within the current radiation protection framework. This is because the biological effects observed in specific cells or animals in the laboratory are a separate issue from whether actual health benefits occur in human populations. In particular, there is insufficient evidence to conclusively prove that intentionally exposing humans to low-dose radiation reduces the incidence of cancer or other diseases.
Therefore, it is necessary today to distinguish between researching the biological adaptation or potential for hormesis from low-dose radiation and claiming that radiation exposure is beneficial to health. The International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) also acknowledges the possibility of hormesis as a subject of research but considers that current data is insufficient to incorporate it into radiation protection systems.
In the past, some studies have even proposed specific numerical values for the safe limits of radiation exposure or the optimal exposure dose at which the hormetic effect is most pronounced. However, these figures should not be interpreted as “health-promoting radiation doses” that the general public should intentionally receive today. The dose limits used in radiation protection are not target doses to be received for health benefits, but rather standards designed to limit unnecessary exposure.
Under the current international radiation protection framework, the effective dose limit for the general public in planned exposure situations is set at 1 mSv per year, while the effective dose limit for radiation workers is set at an annual average of 20 mSv over a five-year period. Of course, general dose limits do not apply directly to radiation exposure for medical purposes; instead, the principles of justification and optimization are applied, taking into account the necessary medical benefits. Therefore, it is inappropriate to interpret radiation protection standards in a way that suggests, “It is safe as long as the dose is below 100 mSv.”

 

How should these differing claims be evaluated?

The three perspectives examined above illustrate important debates regarding the biological effects of low-dose radiation.
However, they should not all be treated as theories with the same level of scientific evidence.
First, the LNT model is a practical model used for radiation protection in situations where it is difficult to directly measure the risks of low-dose radiation. In the low-dose range, it is difficult to distinguish additional cancer cases caused by radiation from those caused by other factors; therefore, methods are used to estimate risks in the low-dose range based on epidemiological data and biological knowledge obtained from medium- and high-dose ranges. Therefore, there is uncertainty in risk estimates based on the LNT model. However, this does not mean that risk estimates based on the LNT model are simply statistical figures without any basis. International organizations evaluate radiation risks by synthesizing epidemiological studies, biological research, and radiation biological mechanisms.
In particular, in the low-dose range of 100 mSv or less, it is difficult to clearly confirm an increased cancer risk due to radiation exposure based on individual studies alone. This does not mean that no risk exists; rather, it means that the magnitude of the risk is so small that it is difficult to confirm directly through statistical analysis. Therefore, “not detectable” and “no risk” are not synonymous.
Conversely, while the radiation adaptation response and the hormesis theory are significant in that they are proposed based on biological phenomena observed in specific experiments, there are limitations to directly applying results from laboratory or animal studies to human health. In particular, the conclusion that exposure to low-dose radiation provides tangible benefits for human cancer incidence or life expectancy has not been established as part of the current scientific and medical consensus.
In the past, criticism was raised regarding the independence of some homeostasis research because it was funded by the nuclear industry. Such criticism highlights the need to consider the source of funding, research design, experimental methods, and reproducibility when evaluating research results. However, one cannot simply conclude that specific research findings are false based solely on the source of funding. Ultimately, to determine the validity of a theory, one must comprehensively review the research methods, data, reproducibility, and evidence from human studies.
Regarding the radiation adaptation response, it is also necessary to distinguish between biological responses observed at the cellular and animal levels and the actual health benefits observed in human populations. Although research into the various biological responses of low-dose and low-dose-rate radiation on living organisms continues today, it is difficult to conclude that these findings provide sufficient evidence to warrant changes to radiation protection standards.

 

Where does the truth lie amid these conflicting claims?

Conflicting claims regarding low-dose radiation have been raised for a long time. On one hand, some argue that the possibility of an increased cancer risk even at low doses must be considered; on the other hand, others contend that the effects of low-dose radiation may not follow a simple linear relationship, citing biological mechanisms such as DNA repair and cellular defense mechanisms. Furthermore, some studies have observed phenomena such as adaptive responses or hormesis.
Therefore, when understanding the risks of low-dose radiation, one should neither conclude that “there is no risk at low doses” nor, conversely, that “even a very small amount of radiation necessarily causes serious harm to health.” Current scientific evidence indicates that the risks of low-dose radiation are far smaller than those of high-dose radiation, and that it is particularly difficult to directly measure the magnitude of these risks at very low doses. Nevertheless, international radiation protection systems do not assume the risk is zero due to this uncertainty; instead, they manage the risk using a conservative and pragmatic approach.
If we apply philosopher of science Karl Popper’s discussion of falsifiability to the issue of radiation, we can view scientific theories not as eternally fixed truths but as knowledge that can be revised in light of new evidence. While we cannot claim that a theory is an absolute truth simply because it has not yet been falsified, the fundamental scientific approach is to accept a theory that has undergone sufficient verification as the most reasonable explanation available at present and to revise it when new evidence emerges.
From this perspective, rather than asserting that the LNT model is an absolute law of nature, it is more appropriate to understand it as a practical model used based on current scientific evidence and the objectives of radiation protection. The International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) employs the LNT assumption as a practical approach to radiation protection in the low-dose range, while simultaneously acknowledging that there is uncertainty in accurately quantifying the magnitude of risk at low doses.
Regarding the Fukushima nuclear accident, more research findings have been accumulated over time. The United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR), after synthesizing the data collected since the accident, assessed that no adverse health effects directly attributable to radiation exposure from the accident have been confirmed among Fukushima residents, and that the likelihood of radiation-related health effects reaching statistically detectable levels in the future is low. Furthermore, since radiation exposure levels among Fukushima Prefecture residents were generally low, the committee assessed that it is unlikely that a detectable excess incidence of certain radiation-sensitive cancers, including thyroid cancer, will occur. However, this assessment does not mean that the risk from radiation is absolutely zero; rather, it means that, given the exposure levels resulting from the accident, the impact is so low that it would be statistically difficult to detect within the population.
This raises the need to reconsider the meaning of the term “safe.” In science, assessing that a risk is very low can have a different meaning than stating in everyday language that “there is absolutely no risk.” In radiation protection as well, dose limits are not a threshold indicating that “radiation below that level is completely harmless,” but rather standards established to manage socially acceptable risk levels and reduce unnecessary exposure. Therefore, dose limits should not be understood as radiation doses that are beneficial to health or as an absolute threshold of safety.
This distinction is likely what the general public is seeking as well. The term “safe” carries a stronger implication than simply meaning that no serious harm has been observed to date. In contrast, science uses expressions such as “the risk is very low” or “it is difficult to confirm statistically based on current research.” Because there is a difference between these two expressions, when the government or experts explain the risks of radiation, it is important to provide specific details—such as the extent of exposure, the known risks at that level, and what remains uncertain—rather than simply using the term “safe.”
Ultimately, the most important fact that current science can state regarding low-dose radiation is that it is neither “completely safe” nor “inevitably harmful even with minimal exposure.” The health effects of radiation depend on factors such as dose, dose rate, the type of radiation, the site of exposure, and individual characteristics; in the low-dose range, there is significant uncertainty in accurately quantifying the risks. However, it is also inappropriate to assume there is no risk simply because of this uncertainty. For this reason, international radiation protection frameworks aim to minimize unnecessary exposure as much as possible and, when necessary, manage the use of radiation by balancing benefits against risks.
Ultimately, rather than choosing between the two terms “safe” and “dangerous,” we must examine the radiation dose, the circumstances of exposure, the health effects confirmed at that level, and the aspects that remain unknown. This is because science is not a discipline that provides immediate, definitive answers to every question, but rather a process of verifying and revising existing explanations as new evidence accumulates.
Therefore, the most prudent way to describe low-dose radiation is not to assert that it is “completely safe” or “definitely dangerous.” Rather, it is to explain both the magnitude of the risk and the associated uncertainties based on the scientific evidence available to date. While we must not exaggerate the risks of radiation, we must also not dismiss the aspects that remain unclear with a simple declaration that it is “safe.” What we need is not rhetoric that fuels fear or offers vague reassurance, but scientific communication that accurately informs us of what has been established and what remains unknown.

 

About the author

Cam Tien

I love things that are gentle and cute. I love dogs, cats, and flowers because they make me happy. I also enjoy eating and traveling to discover new things. Besides that, I like to lie back, take in the scenery, and relax to enjoy life.