In this blog post, we will examine efficient green energy usage and optimization strategies based on a study that analyzed the appropriate scale and cost-effectiveness of power generation facilities and storage systems for schools, using ESS and smart grids to compensate for the irregular power output of renewable energy.
- ESS: Overcoming the Limitations of Renewable Energy
- What are smart grids and distributed energy systems?
- How is the optimal scale of power generation facilities and ESS calculated?
- How does the output of a wind turbine vary with wind speed?
- How much does power generation vary depending on the wind turbine model?
- How can the optimal ESS capacity be determined?
- How will the decline in ESS prices change the research results?
- Can ESS and smart grids enhance the feasibility of green energy?
ESS: Overcoming the Limitations of Renewable Energy
This article was written to explain how to efficiently utilize green energy, based on the author’s research titled “A Study on the Feasibility of Establishing a School Power Grid Using ESS and Smart Grids.” Since the beginning of the 21st century, as the need to address climate change, achieve carbon neutrality, and ensure energy security has grown, the world has focused on expanding renewable energy sources, including solar and wind power. Fossil fuels emit greenhouse gases and air pollutants during combustion, and nuclear power also faces separate challenges, such as spent nuclear fuel management and radioactive waste disposal. Consequently, technologies for converting energy from sustainable natural sources—such as solar and wind power—into electricity have advanced rapidly. However, since solar and wind power are variable renewable energy sources whose output fluctuates depending on weather and time of day, ensuring flexibility is crucial for stabilizing the balance between supply and demand in the power grid. Currently, key solutions include expanding transmission and distribution networks, interconnecting power grids across regions, implementing demand response, forecasting power generation, utilizing flexibility resources, and deploying Energy Storage Systems (ESS). ESS can enhance the balance of power supply and demand and improve grid stability by storing excess electricity generated during periods of high output and releasing it when generation is insufficient or demand is high. In particular, the price of battery-based ESS has fallen significantly compared to the past, and as technology and the market have grown rapidly, the potential for utilizing systems that combine renewable energy with ESS has increased. Therefore, while ensuring economic viability—due to high ESS prices and power generation facility installation costs—was a key research challenge in the past, today economic viability must be evaluated by considering not only falling battery prices but also electricity rate structures, demand patterns, grid interconnection costs, maintenance costs, battery lifespan, and replacement costs.
What are smart grids and distributed energy systems?
First, it is necessary to examine what a smart grid is. A smart grid does not simply refer to the practice of installing power generation facilities close to where electricity is consumed. It refers to an intelligent power grid that integrates information and communication technology (ICT) and digital control technology into the existing power grid to monitor information on power generation, transmission, distribution, and consumption in real time or near real time, thereby coordinating power supply and demand more efficiently. On the other hand, installing facilities such as solar power generation, small-scale wind power generation, and energy storage systems (ESS) near electricity consumption points—such as buildings or schools—is more closely related to the concept of distributed energy or distributed energy resources. In the past, power supply was primarily based on a centralized structure, where electricity generated at large-scale power plants was transmitted to consumption sites via transmission and distribution grids; however, today, distributed systems—which generate, store, and consume electricity close to the point of consumption—are expanding alongside these existing power grids. Distributed energy resources can include solar power systems on buildings and battery storage devices, among others, and smart grids can play a role in effectively integrating and controlling these resources with the existing power grid. Since solar and wind power generation varies depending on the time of day and weather conditions, stable operation may be difficult if the generated power is consumed as-is. In such cases, using an ESS in conjunction with these systems allows power to be stored during periods of high generation and supplied during periods of low generation. Therefore, by appropriately integrating smart grids, distributed energy, and ESS, renewable energy can be utilized more efficiently and reliably.
How is the optimal scale of power generation facilities and ESS calculated?
The basic research approach in this study involved first determining the scale of the power generation facilities, then setting the ESS capacity accordingly, and finally calculating the economic value that can be derived from this configuration. Since generating electricity on-site using renewable energy reduces the amount of power that must be purchased from the grid, the resulting reduction in power purchase costs can be viewed as an economic benefit. In this study, meteorological data from the past year was used to obtain information on solar irradiance and wind speed; this data was then combined with the output characteristics and efficiency of the planned power generation units to estimate the amount of electricity that could be generated by time period or over the course of a day. While this approach remains valid in principle, evaluating actual project viability requires incorporating recent meteorological data, actual load patterns, power generation equipment prices, ESS installation costs, electricity rate structures, charge/discharge efficiency, battery degradation, maintenance costs, and grid connection conditions. The study assessed economic feasibility primarily from two perspectives. The first was the payback period—the time required to recover the initial investment costs for power generation facilities and ESS, among other components—and the second was the economic benefit that could be obtained over one year of system operation. By utilizing these criteria, it is possible to determine the most economically viable facility scale—one that balances investment costs and cost-saving effects—rather than simply maximizing power generation capacity.
How does the output of a wind turbine vary with wind speed?
The first renewable energy source selected for this study was wind energy. Since the output of a wind turbine varies with wind speed, calculating the actual amount of electricity that can be generated in a specific region requires examining both the turbine’s output curve and local wind speed data. Generally, wind turbines do not generate power when the wind is very weak; they begin generating power once a certain wind speed is reached. As wind speed increases, the turbine’s output also increases, and once the rated wind speed is reached, the turbine is controlled to maintain its rated output within a certain range. Conversely, if wind speeds become excessively high, operation is halted to prevent mechanical damage to the turbine and ensure safety. Therefore, when evaluating the economic viability of wind power, it is not sufficient to consider only the simple average wind speed; the actual potential power generation must be calculated by applying both the hourly wind speed distribution and the turbine’s power curve.
How much does power generation vary depending on the wind turbine model?
The study utilized historical wind speed data from the Incheon region to determine the wind turbine model. It employed a method of calculating the expected power generation by applying the hourly wind speed data collected over 365 days to the output characteristics of the turbines. The comparison involved three models with rated outputs of 20 kW, 30 kW, and 50 kW, respectively. The results, calculated by combining the Incheon wind speed data used in the study with the output characteristics of each turbine, indicated that the 20 kW model was the most suitable. It is important to note here that a turbine with a higher rated output does not necessarily generate greater economic benefits in a specific region. Wind turbines can operate efficiently only when the wind conditions at the installation site align with the turbine’s start-up wind speed, rated wind speed, rated output, and power curve. Therefore, if the same study were to be conducted today, the appropriate model would need to be selected by analyzing recent long-term wind data, the topography and obstacle conditions at the actual installation site, the latest power curves for each turbine model, and installation and maintenance costs.
How can the optimal ESS capacity be determined?
The second study focused on determining the optimal battery capacity and assessing its practical feasibility. The study used the payback period—the time required to recover the initial costs of installing the power generation facilities and the ESS—as the primary metric for evaluating economic efficiency, and analyzed at what ESS capacity investment efficiency is maximized. Simply increasing the ESS capacity does not necessarily lead to continued improvements in economic viability. If the storage capacity is too small, it may not be able to store enough generated power, potentially wasting usable renewable energy; conversely, if the storage capacity is excessively large, the initial investment costs may rise excessively due to unused storage capacity. In that study, a method was used in which the ESS capacity was increased in fixed increments through program coding, the payback periods for each scenario were compared, and the most economical capacity was identified. While current ESS optimization can still utilize this basic principle, recent approaches can also take into account a wider range of variables, such as charge/discharge efficiency, battery degradation, time-of-use electricity price differences, peak load reduction, demand response, avoidance of renewable energy output curtailment, and grid services.
How will the decline in ESS prices change the research results?
The original study assumed an ESS price of approximately 600,000 won per kWh and applied a separate scenario projecting that prices could fall to around 180,000 won in the future. Calculations based on the original price indicated that an ESS capacity of 79 kWh was the most economical, with an initial investment payback period of approximately 12.2 years. The study calculated daily savings of up to approximately 28,883 won, with an average of about 18,407 won per day; when annualized, this was estimated to result in economic savings of approximately 6.7 million won. Conversely, in a scenario where the ESS price drops to approximately 180,000 won per kWh, the optimal ESS capacity increased to 170 kWh, and the payback period for the initial investment was significantly reduced to about 5.4 years. In this case, the maximum daily savings were calculated at approximately 60,076 won, and the average daily economic benefit was approximately 35,600 won; the analysis indicated that this would result in an annual economic benefit of approximately 13 million won. However, since these figures were calculated based on conditions used in the study at that time—such as electricity consumption, wind conditions, equipment prices, electricity rates, and battery prices—they should not be taken as a direct reflection of the actual economic viability of current projects. Currently, the price of battery storage systems has dropped significantly compared to the past, and according to the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), installation costs for utility-scale battery storage projects worldwide have fallen sharply over the long term. Therefore, if a new analysis were to be conducted for the same school today, the optimal capacity and payback period would need to be recalculated using the latest ESS prices, electricity rates, power generation facility installation costs, and battery replacement and maintenance costs.
Can ESS and smart grids enhance the feasibility of green energy?
Summarizing the findings of this study, it is clear that when combining renewable energy generation facilities with ESS, it is crucial to determine the appropriate facility scale by considering the initial investment cost, payback period, and long-term electricity cost savings together. Furthermore, it has been confirmed that economic viability can be enhanced not by simply setting the capacity of power generation facilities and ESS as large as possible, but by optimizing them according to local weather conditions and actual electricity demand. In particular, as battery storage prices have fallen significantly compared to the past and the adoption of variable renewable energy sources such as solar and wind power has expanded, ESS is now being utilized not merely as a device for storing electricity but as a critical resource for enhancing the flexibility of the power grid. Batteries can store electricity generated during periods of high renewable energy production and shift it to times of high demand, thereby contributing to maintaining grid balance and ensuring stable operation. However, actual economic viability varies significantly depending on factors such as the installation site, electricity consumption patterns, renewable energy resources, electricity rates, battery prices, charging and discharging methods, and grid connection conditions; therefore, separate analyses are required for each individual project. Ultimately, the key point presented in this study is that renewable energy generation facilities, ESS, and smart grids must be viewed as a single system, and generation, storage capacity, and consumption must be optimized together. This approach remains valid today, and as technological advancements, falling ESS prices, and the digitization of the power grid continue, its importance in building an efficient, stable, and eco-friendly energy system is growing even further.