In this blog post, we’ll examine the principle of work hardening—the process by which metals become stronger when hammered or pressed—and explore topics ranging from the difference between elastic and plastic deformation to the effects of processing temperature and heat treatment on metal properties.
- Permanent deformation is what makes metal stronger
- Dislocations deform metals and hinder the movement of other atoms
- Why does metal react differently when hammered while hot?
- Even if strength increases, workability and toughness do not necessarily improve as well.
- Rolling, Extrusion, and Forging Alter Both Shape and Internal Microstructure
Permanent deformation is what makes metal stronger
Metals generally become stronger when they are permanently deformed by hammering or pressing at sufficiently low temperatures. This is because dislocations—linear defects in the atomic arrangement within the metal—increase and hinder each other’s movement, requiring greater stress to cause further deformation. This phenomenon is called work hardening or deformation hardening. However, not all metals become infinitely stronger with each working operation. If the working temperature is too high, the hardening effect may diminish, and excessive deformation can lead to cracking or fracture.
To understand this principle, we must first distinguish between the two types of deformation that occur when a force is applied. Elastic deformation is deformation that returns to its original shape when the force is removed, while plastic deformation is deformation that leaves a permanent change in shape even after the force is removed. Work hardening in metals is related to plastic deformation.
If you stretch a rubber band moderately and then release it, it returns almost to its original length. This is an easy-to-visualize example of elastic deformation. Metals also deform elastically when subjected to small forces, but the changes are often too small to be noticeable to the naked eye compared to a rubber band. However, since rubber and metal have different internal structures, the principle of rubber band stretching cannot be directly applied to metals.
Stress is the magnitude of the force acting within a material expressed per unit area, while strain indicates how much the material has elongated or contracted relative to its original length. Within the linear elastic range of metals, Hooke’s law holds, meaning that stress and strain are proportional. However, just because a deformation is elastic does not mean that all materials exhibit this proportional relationship throughout their entire elastic range.
The phenomenon in which plastic deformation begins as the stress applied to a metal increases is called yield, and the corresponding stress is referred to as the yield strength. Since yield may occur abruptly or gradually depending on the metal, the yield strength of materials without a distinct yield point is evaluated based on a specified amount of permanent deformation. When we say that a metal becomes stronger through work hardening, it specifically means that the stress required to initiate or sustain such permanent deformation increases.
Dislocations deform metals and hinder the movement of other atoms
Inside a metal, atoms are arranged according to certain rules to form a crystal. However, actual crystals are not perfect, and dislocations—where the atomic arrangement is locally disrupted—exist. In many metals, plastic deformation occurs as these dislocations move along specific planes and directions within the crystal.
The presence of dislocations allows the atomic arrangement to shift gradually without the entire atomic layer moving all at once. Therefore, dislocations enable metals to undergo permanent deformation even under relatively low stress. This is why the movement of dislocations is crucial for understanding why metals can be rolled thin, stretched long, and formed into desired shapes.
However, as plastic deformation continues, dislocations multiply, and the interactions between them increase. As dislocations become entangled with one another or act as obstacles that hinder movement, further displacement becomes difficult. The dislocations that initially enabled the metal’s deformation actually increase resistance to deformation once their number grows. In this state, a greater stress than before is required to induce further plastic deformation.
The change becomes clear when considering a situation where a metal undergoes a single plastic deformation and the force is then removed. When the force is removed, the portion corresponding to elastic deformation returns to its original state, but the shape change caused by plastic deformation remains. If a load is subsequently applied in the same direction without altering the internal microstructure—such as through heat treatment—the work-hardened metal generally begins to undergo plastic deformation again at a higher stress level than before.
What is important here is not simply the fact that the metal was struck multiple times, but whether plastic deformation actually occurred and how the dislocation structure changed during that process. It is not the case that all the work applied to the metal is stored internally, resulting in a corresponding increase in strength. A significant portion of the energy used for plastic deformation is converted into heat, and some is stored as energy associated with defects; work hardening must be explained by changes in the internal structure that hinder dislocation movement.
Why does metal react differently when hammered while hot?
Work hardening is typically most pronounced during cold working. Cold working does not simply mean working cold metal; rather, it refers to the process of applying plastic deformation under low-temperature conditions where recovery and recrystallization do not proceed sufficiently during processing. While this is commonly done at room temperature, what constitutes a “low temperature” varies depending on the type of metal.
If work-hardened metal is heated to an appropriate temperature, recovery may occur, in which dislocations are rearranged or partially eliminated. Under the right conditions, recrystallization also takes place, resulting in the formation and growth of new grains with lower dislocation density. Grains are the small crystalline regions that make up a metal. These changes reduce the hardening effect accumulated during working and restore the metal to a state where it is easier to deform.
In hot working, where metal is deformed at sufficiently high temperatures, recovery and recrystallization can occur even during the working process. Since the effects of dislocation growth and dislocation structure reorganization act simultaneously, it cannot be viewed as a continuous accumulation of hardening, as in cold working. The final strength is influenced not only by the working temperature but also by the deformation rate, the amount of deformation, the cooling process, and the alloy composition.
This is also why it is difficult to explain the process of a blacksmith hammering heated iron solely in terms of work hardening. In traditional metalworking, forming, heating, and cooling occurred simultaneously, and the metal’s internal microstructure and properties changed during this process. In particular, the hardening resulting from the quenching of steel is primarily related to phase transformation—that is, a change in the internal crystalline structure. A distinction must be made between work hardening achieved by hammering and hardening achieved through heat treatment.
Even if strength increases, workability and toughness do not necessarily improve as well.
A metal’s performance cannot be judged by strength alone. Strength is the degree of resistance to deformation or fracture, while hardness is the degree of resistance to localized deformation, such as indentation. Ductility is the ability to undergo plastic deformation before fracture, while toughness refers to the ability to absorb energy before failure. Although they are related, they are not the same property.
In general cold working, while strength and hardness tend to increase, ductility—the margin for further deformation—tends to decrease. Therefore, one should not assume that simply because the material has become stronger, it will be more resistant to impact or easier to form into the desired shape. Excessive processing can lead to cracks or product failure.
In manufacturing, these limitations are taken into account by combining processing with heat treatment. If significant deformation must be applied over multiple stages, an intermediate stress-relief heat treatment is sometimes performed to alleviate hardening and restore ductility before proceeding to the next processing step. Any resulting slight decrease in strength is an intentional adjustment made to enable subsequent processing.
Work hardening is not the only method for strengthening metals. Other methods include altering the alloy composition, adjusting grain size, forming fine particles within the metal, or inducing phase transformations through heat treatment. The choice of method depends on the type of metal and the properties required for the product. The actual goal is not merely to maximize strength, but to combine strength, ductility, toughness, and formability in a way that suits the intended application.
Rolling, Extrusion, and Forging Alter Both Shape and Internal Microstructure
Humankind has empirically utilized the fact that a metal’s properties change during the process of shaping it into the desired form. The discovery of materials and the advancement of processing technologies were the driving forces behind how the use of bronze and iron transformed toolmaking and how the widespread adoption of iron farming implements contributed to agricultural production.
The value of metals lies not only in their properties as found in nature but also in the ability to impart the necessary shape and performance by applying force and heat.
Typical metal forming methods include rolling, extrusion, and forging. Rolling is a method of reducing the thickness of metal or forming a cross-section by passing it between rotating rolls. Extrusion is a method of forcing metal through a die opening to create a product with a uniform cross-section, while forging is a method of changing the shape by applying compressive force using a hammer or press.
These processes do more than just alter the external shape. Depending on the processing conditions, the shape of the grain, the distribution of grain orientation, and the dislocation structure change, which in turn affects the mechanical properties of the final product. Even for the same process—such as rolling or forging—the degree of hardening and changes in internal microstructure differ depending on whether the process is performed cold or hot. Therefore, one cannot determine a product’s strength based solely on the name of the processing method.
The key reason metals become stronger when hammered is that the dislocations created by plastic deformation hinder each other’s movement. However, in the production of useful metal products, the technology for controlling hardening through temperature and heat treatment is just as important as the technology for achieving work hardening. Metals used in automobiles, ships, buildings, and industrial facilities undergo this control to withstand the necessary loads while taking on the shapes required during the manufacturing process. The significance of metalworking lies in designing the properties of the material so that, while creating a shape, that shape can perform its intended function.